Wednesday, July 11, 2012

MALEY ON REFUGEES


SICK of SPIN - Here is an experts view. From Pamela Curr, 10.7.12

AS the dust settles following the parliament's emotionally charged debate on refugee policy, several points have emerged with considerable clarity.

First, Rob Oakeshott's proposal that the Immigration Minister be authorised to send asylum-seekers to countries that are parties to the so-called "Bali Process" is a non-starter. This is no bad thing. North Korea and Syria are both parties to the Bali Process, and any proposal that in principle would allow people to be dispatched to such hell-holes is clearly absurd.

Second, the Gillard government's "Malaysia Solution" has hit a dead-end, too. The Greens are not going to shift from their implacable hostility to "offshore processing". More seriously, the opposition leadership team is plainly not going to alter its position either and, while its stance carries a strong whiff of opportunism, the opposition happens to be right that there are huge dangers in transporting vulnerable asylum-seekers by force to a country that is not a party to the 1951 Refugee Convention, and in which (as the High Court emphasised last year) the "protections" that would be offered to such asylum-seekers have no legal force.

Where does this leave us? The opposition's answer is obvious: Nauru. It worked in the past, they claim, and will work again. Unfortunately, this assertion is spurious. The seeming "success" of the Pacific Solution had much more to do with the evaporation of "push factors" in Afghanistan when the Taliban regime was overthrown in Operation Enduring Freedom in November 2001, and those push factors have come surging back with the Taliban's re-emergence. There is no sign they will disappear any time soon.

Furthermore, large numbers of those consigned to Nauru came to Australia, with most of the others resettled in New Zealand. Because this is known to have happened last time Nauru was used, its credibility as a deterrent is weak. In any case, if the situation in Afghanistan takes a further turn for the worse, we could easily witness refugee flows that would quickly overwhelm Nauru. And while a few small countries might be bribed to take refugees who have reached Australia, no major party to the 1951 convention will agree to do so.

To mask this rather obvious point, the opposition has mooted two measures: the resumption of the use of "temporary protection visas" (TPVs), and the forced return of boats to Indonesia. Anyone who would buy this as serious policy is gullible enough to be sold the Brooklyn Bridge.

From almost every conceivable viewpoint, the promotion of TPVs is a foolish idea. First proposed by Pauline Hanson, and introduced in 1999, they had no discernible effect on the disposition of asylum-seekers to approach Australia for protection. Since one of the visa conditions was that TPV holders could not sponsor spouses and young children to join them, a new market was created for the services that people-smugglers were trying to sell: it was almost as if the smugglers and the Australian government were in cahoots. The psychological effects, moreover, were devastating: unable to get on with their lives, TPV holders all too often buckled under the stress, succumbing to mental health problems with which the health system will have to cope at considerable cost for years to come. While permanent protection is not explicitly required by the 1951 convention, in a world of sensible policymaking, temporary protection should be used only in very limited and specific circumstances, where safe return of refugees to their homes is likely to occur within a matter of weeks or months.

Trying to turn boats around is just as foolish. Refugee boats tend to be ramshackle structures, and attempting to turn them back is a recipe for a disaster. Moreover, such a high-handed approach by Australia would imperil the prospects of even modest co-operation from Jakarta and other regional capitals in addressing asylum-seeker issues. Their response to arrogance from Canberra would probably be to let any boats sail that the smugglers could find.

Refugee problems are complex, and cannot be solved by pulling rabbits out of hats. "Deterrence" on its own is simply a device for ensuring refugees drown in the Mediterranean rather than in our neighbourhood.

Attention to root causes, and serious regional co-operation, is the only way of ameliorating the asylum-seeker problem. Herein lies the rub. If regional states are to become venues for processing refugee claims from asylum-seekers who would otherwise approach Australia, then Australia will have to agree to resettle really large numbers of refugees, primarily Afghans fearing the return of the Taliban, from those states. This will cost more money -- at which point we will discover how much our MPs and senators really care about saving lives at sea.

Professor William Maley is Director of the Asia-Pacific College of Diplomacy at the Australian National University, and author of Rescuing Afghanistan.

Thursday, June 28, 2012

MEDIA RELEASE LABOR FOR REFUGEES 28.6.12


MEDIA RELEASE



"Labor for Refugees has today expressed its disgust with the way the Government has failed to step up and deal with the asylum seeker boat issue in open, fair and honest manner. The coalition is no better." said NSW Labor for Refugees co-convenor Mr. Prince today.



Mr Robin Rothfield, Secretary of Labor for Refugees Victoria added: "Both major parties in Parliament are blinded by their obsession with outdoing each other in punishing the very people they cry for. These poor people will be punished if they are forcibly sent to either Malaysia or Nauru."



Mr Prince said: "Labor for Refugees is embarrassed to say that  only the Green's solution identifies a decent and realistic way of stopping the boats. It is the same solution Malcolm Fraser successfully employed to stop the boats to Australia from Vietnam. Refugees should be brought to Australia in an orderly way- where our Government takes responsibility for bringing them here. "



Mr Prince went on to say: "Successive governments, including Labor Governments, have created this problem by only allowing an average of 56 refugees a year over 10 years to come to Australia from Indonesia- out of a total of 13,500 available places. They then blame the victims for trying to reach freedom.



In fact from the beginning of this year until 31 May - only 24 refugees were resettled from Indonesia to Australia that’s from a pool of 5,732 places available for asylum seekers and refugees. The Government is just not trying to find a solution which does not include punishment."



"It is the Government which is being intransigent and purist about not creating an orderly queue for refugees in Indonesia. ", Mr Prince said.



"This is not an insurmountable problem. There are only 4,239 asylum seekers in all of Indonesia. An orderly queue could easily be formed if there was the courage in Government to do so. People would then no longer take desperate measures- at the moment they have no choice because of the Government's policies." said Mr. Prince.



Mr Robin Rothfield, said: "Deterrence just does not work. The Howard Government got lucky because when those policies came into force, refugee numbers across the world fell by more than half. The politicians are kidding themselves by thinking their policies stopped people from seeking freedom."



Labor for Refugees called on the leadership of the Party to step up, put forward a positive proposal and stop trying to act tough. Mr. Prince said: "Our members in the Labor Party share the community frustration with the failure of the politicians in dealing with these problems in a fair dinkum way."



ENDS



Labor for Refugees NSW and Victoria represent many hundreds of active rank and file members of the ALP who are committed to fair and decent treatment of asylum seekers and compliance with the Refugee Convention.



Media enquiries



Shane Prince 0416 229 338, Co-Convenor Labor for Refugees NSW



Robin Rothfield 03 9486 5973 , Secretary Labor for Refugees VIC

Mob 0418 338 665

Saturday, June 23, 2012

FOLEY ON WALKER IN PARLIAMENT


The Hon. LUKE FOLEY (Leader of the Opposition) [7.03 p.m.], 22.6.12: Today I attended the State funeral of the Hon. Francis John Walker, QC. I believe Frank Walker was one of the most successful politicians that New South Wales Labor has ever produced. By that I mean that Frank Walker had the privilege of serving as a Minister of the Crown for 12 years at the State level and three years at the Federal level, and he enacted a wide range of important reforms to the laws of our State and country. Frank Walker was elected to the seat of Georges River in a by-election in 1970. He was an organiser for Neville Wran to replace Pat Hills in the leadership of the State parliamentary Labor Party in December 1973. He was elected to the ministry when Labor came to office in 1976. During the next 12 years Frank Walker variously served in the following ministries: Attorney General, Justice, Aboriginal Affairs, Community Services, Youth, Housing, the Arts and Leader of the House.

The 1970 Georges River by-election that brought Frank to Parliament was hard fought. In a blatant piece of electioneering, then Premier Robert Askin promised to introduce a Summary Offences Act. Notwithstanding that, Frank overwhelmingly defeated the Liberal Party in that by-election, winning a seat for Labor from the then Government. Nine years later Frank Walker repealed the Summary Offences Act. In the cognate crimes bills and cognate summary offences bills that Walker shepherded through this Parliament in 1979 he amended 16 pieces of legislation. In 1976, 55,000 people in New South Wales were arrested for public drunkenness. People were arrested, brought before the courts, fined, some were imprisoned, often repeatedly, because they could not stump up $1 for bail. In 1979 in the other place Frank Walker said:

This Government intends to remedy that completely unsatisfactory situation by implementing provisions which will ensure that the law is placed on a rational and humane basis.



That was Walker's approach to law reform. He abolished the crime of being poor and the law preventing peaceful public protest. The definition of "offensive behaviour" was amended to move away from any conduct that offended the arresting police officer to a reasonable man test. Appeals to the Privy Council in London were abolished. The Legal Aid Commission and community justice centres were established. Compassionate treatment of victims of sexual assault came about. Aboriginal land rights legislation was introduced in 1983. It was a historic reform in the history of this State. As Minister for Housing, Frank Walker ceased constructing suburbs of public housing and instead engaged in partnerships with the private sector to mix public housing with private estates.



Frank Walker was committed to parliamentary democracy, civil liberties, human rights, equality before the law, and a tolerant and inclusive society. Frank Walker was also one of the most effective marginal seat campaigners modern New South Wales politics has seen. He was always at the cutting edge of modern campaigning and marketing techniques. Walker's organisation of postal votes in seats such as Blue Mountains and Hurstville in the 1976 campaign played no small part in getting Labor across the line. For Frank Walker possessed both conviction and cunning.



I thank Premier Barry O'Farrell for granting Frank Walker a State funeral today. I also acknowledge the terrific speech delivered by the Minister for Police, the Hon. Michael Gallacher, on behalf of the Government. I sent my condolences to Frank's widow, Pam, and his brother, Robert. I am proud to call Frank Walker a comrade and friend. I salute his service to this State and his great reformist achievements.

Thursday, June 21, 2012

PRIMROSE ON WORKERS COMPENSATION


The Hon. PETER PRIMROSE [1.03 a.m.]: I refer to the Workers Compensation Legislation Amendment Bill 2012 and the Safety, Return to Work and Support Board Bill 2012. This is truly disgusting legislation.
I will refer to the legislation that indicates something of the mindset of those who drafted it. I refer to page 37, line 15, in schedule 2 to the Workers Compensation Legislation Amendment Bill, which states:
2.3 Amendment of Civil Liability Act 2002 No 22

Section 26I Non-economic loss damages limited to workers compensation amount

Omit section 26I (2). Insert instead:
(2) When determining the total amount to which a worker would be entitled as compensation under a provision of the Workers Compensation Act 1987, the amount is to be determined under the provision as it was in force when the injury to the offender was received

According to this legislation, workers with injuries are "offenders". That gives us an interesting insight into the mindset of those who drafted this legislation. No longer will non-economic loss damages be limited to the workers compensation amount for a worker, who is described as an "offender" in this legislation. Certainly this legislation is offensive, not the injured worker. The O'Farrell Government will financially and emotionally devastate injured workers and their families with its unprecedented cuts to workers compensation in New South Wales. I have heard nothing but indignation in the past couple of months from so-called family defenders against the marriage equality legislation, and how families will be destroyed by same-sex relationships, yet I have not heard one word of protest from those same family defenders about the draconian changes proposed by the O'Farrell Government to workers compensation.

Mothers and fathers who are injured while they are trying to earn a living will be financially crippled by this legislation. In some cases, families will lose their homes and be placed in poverty. Some mothers and fathers will decide they can no longer cope. The changes proposed by this legislation will apply retrospectively to injured workers and their families. Injured workers currently living week to week on medical benefits and entitlements will be left unable to support themselves and their families. Earlier today we saw the spectacle of Premier Barry O'Farrell claiming that the laws were not retrospective, and as we now know that is plainly wrong. The retrospective application of his appalling cuts is there in black and white in his own legislation. This morning on ABC breakfast the Premier said the changes would not be retrospective:
Angela Catterns: So retrospective changes, how far back?

Premier O'Farrell: No they are not.

This is completely at odds with the legislation. Schedule 12, paragraph 3 (1) clearly states:
(1) Except as provided by this Part or the regulations, an amendment made by the 2012 amending Act extends to:
(a) an injury received before the commencement of the amendment, and

Schedule 12 to the bill also states that an insurer has 12 months to conduct a work capacity assessment of an existing recipient of weekly payments, and three months after the insurer makes that assessment the cut to weekly payment applies. Even workplace lawyers have criticised Premier O'Farrell for suggesting that the retrospectivity of these laws does not apply. On 20 June Mr Ivan Simic, a partner at Taylor and Scott lawyers, stated on the Linda Mottrem ABC show:
The legislation is horribly retrospective. He is absolutely wrong. He is either telling a lie or he doesn't understand his own legislation.

The Premier has misled the public about the fact that these changes will not come into effect until the Governor signs off on them. According to the legislation, that is plain wrong. The legislation provides for some amendments to have operation on and from 19 June 2012. Medical benefits for injured workers will be cut off after one year, forcing those who do not receive surgery within one year of their injury, or those who are forced to endure ongoing treatment, into destitution. The O'Farrell Government will reduce benefits to injured workers from the day after they are injured, with a further reduction after 13 weeks of their injury.

The Premier will completely cut off benefits to large numbers of injured workers after five years, even if the injured worker is permanently injured and cannot return to work. Journey claims will be axed completely, which means a nurse finishing a double shift who is seriously injured in an accident on the way home will receive no assistance and be left completely destitute. Workplace injuries cannot be predicted. They can happen to anyone, at any point in their career, and can devastate families already struggling to keep their heads above water. These are disgraceful cuts that will hurt those who can least afford it—people who are simply unlucky enough to be injured at work, and their families.

The philosophy that has always underpinned workers compensation schemes is straightforward: someone who is injured at work and cannot work should be compensated for as long as they cannot work; and that compensation should include payment of their medical treatments and medical bills for as long as they cannot work. This philosophy includes the view that employers who have been negligent should be required to contribute their fair share to that payment of compensation so that the burden does not fall on taxpayers. Yet, ironically, the amendments in this legislation will put a greater impost on the taxpayers of New South Wales.

Premier O'Farrell's argument that workers compensation premiums will have to rise by 28 per cent if members do not allow these amendments to pass is, frankly, untrue. In the WorkCover New South Wales executive summary "Actuarial valuations of outstanding claims … to 31 December 2011", Michael Playford and David Wright from PricewaterhouseCoopers, the Government's own actuaries, say on page 2 that the buffer between the collection of premiums and payouts is not sufficient to return the scheme to surplus within a reasonable time. The question then becomes: What does "reasonable time" mean? Turn to page 3:
The projections indicate that (with no other changes)—

and that is the key
—aspiring to return to full funding by 5 years would require a premium rate increase in the order of 28%.

Full funding in five years "with no other changes"—but no-one is proposing that. They go on to say that aspiring to return to full funding by 10 years "would require a premium rate increase in the order of only 8%." Opposition members asked Mr Playford in evidence before the Joint Select Committee on the NSW Workers Compensation Scheme, "What would be a reasonable time?" He indicated between five and 10 years would be a reasonable time. And the premium increase is in the order of only 8 per cent, not 28 per cent as the Premier keeps claiming.

Premier O'Farrell also makes no mention of the fact that in New South Wales in the past five years premiums have been discounted by 33 per cent. The threat of a 28 per cent rise in premiums is just a myth. What is true is that premiums have been discounted by 33 per cent—in the order of $7 billion—in the past five years.

We all have to acknowledge that there are problems with the workers compensation scheme. But what are they, and what should be done to remedy them? The select committee heard from witness after witness, from submission and oral evidence right across the industrial spectrum, from people such as Garry Bracks through to Mark Lennon and from all the injured workers and insurance companies themselves, that there were problems with the scheme's agents and claims management. But not even one recommendation embodied in this legislation before us today goes to those pieces of evidence. Insurance companies were getting paid more for processing fewer claims. Allianz Australia Workers' Compensation (NSW) Limited said this about the government guidelines:
While there are guidelines and procedures available to Agents to return workers to full health and back into the work place, they are far from effectual as they are:

· Ambiguous and open to variable interpretation

· Not enforceable

· Inconsistently applied

· Not used by all parties involved in decision making regarding claims
In our experience, many claims are extended beyond the treatment of the original injury and regularly encompass related physical conditions, pre-existing or degenerative conditions, and secondary psychological conditions (such as depression and anxiety).

This is one of the insurance companies in the scheme saying that the process is difficult and untenable. But nothing in this legislation goes towards fixing up any of these problems. There were repeated instances of evidence about the difficulties in returning people to work; that employers would not give people a job after they had been injured; that people who were trying to get back to work were having quite some difficulty doing so. All of those problems have been ignored by the O'Farrell Government. There are many instances of matters that were given in evidence but which remained ignored. For example, Ernst and Young in its 2012 peer review report, while acknowledging the changes implemented in 2011, recommended that WorkCover review its overall approach to management of the scheme, and in particular the management of agents, including their remuneration, and conduct a back to basics review of that remuneration. Nothing in the legislation we have before us today addresses this concern either.

The final report of the select committee ignored the evidence that had been presented to the committee. The sham report was presented by a sham committee, stacked with four Government members and two other members who voted with Government members on 95 per cent of the recommendations, and only two Opposition members. Yet even it recommends further and ongoing review of the workers compensation scheme; in fact, it wants a joint select committee to be established to look at the way the scheme is working; and wants the New South Wales Government to review the functions, powers and behaviours available to the scheme agent. If it is so important that a joint select committee be established to extensively review WorkCover and the workers compensation scheme in New South Wales, what is the reason for the Government's headlong rush to do one thing, and only one thing—to cut benefits to workers? All that evidence was ignored by the Government in its mad rush to reduce benefits to New South Wales workers. In submission 131 the NSW Self Insurance Corporation, the Treasury, says very clearly:
Our main recommendation is that the Committee seek to have the impact of any proposed reforms scenario tested and actuarially costed to understand the implications on the TMF [Treasury Managed Fund] before deciding on the package of reforms to be implemented.

But Premier O'Farrell is not stopping to wait for that. Treasury in New South Wales is being ignored.

Under this legislation "seriously injured worker" means a worker whose injury has resulted in permanent impairment and the degree of permanent impairment has been assessed for the purposes of division 4 to be more than 30 per cent. During the select committee hearing Michael Gliksman, Vice President of the Australian Medical Association, and Peter John Burke, a medical-surgical specialist representing the Australian Medical Association and the Australian Association of Surgeons delegate to the Medico Legal Committee, the Law Society of New South Wales, were asked what their opinion was of increasing the threshold to 30 per cent. They were asked how many would make it through the 30 per cent threshold. Dr Gliksman replied:
Very few. In my experience of those I see who I feel have a genuine work-related injury less than one in 100 people would get to the 30 per cent threshold. In my opinion it would shut the system down as a means of support.

Dr Burke replied:
I agree with that. It is one in 100. It would severely damage the average person who is genuinely injured at work.

Roshana May and Timothy Concannon, members of the Injury Compensation Committee of the Law Society of New South Wales, and Justin Dowd, President of the Law Society were asked the same question: What would happen if the 30 per cent impairment level suggested in the issues paper—and now this legislation—was imposed? Mr Concannon replied:
In my experiences of working under the scheme, I have had two or maybe three workers, amongst thousands of workers I have acted for over that period, who would satisfy that requirement.
                   Ms May was asked whether it was true that only 100 claimants or so in the scheme were currently receiving ongoing care.

Ms May replied:
Yes, I think it is more like 110; I am sorry, I do not have the figure.

She was then asked whether there were not thousands, and she replied:
There are not thousands ... The best estimate of the Injury Compensation Committee is that it would reduce lump sum payments, if you are talking about that, to more than 95 per cent of the current injured population


I will provide the House with a few examples in the time that I have left. A 35-year-old man sustained a crush injury and had a below-knee amputation. He lost his leg and was assessed as having a 28 per cent impairment. A 25-year-old man who suffered back and thigh pain while twisting underwent a discectomy three months after the injury. He still has back pain but has been assessed as having a 10 per cent impairment. A 35-year-old man had a surgical discectomy three months after an injury and has persistent back and thigh pain, numbness along his foot, is unable to do his usual recreational activities and some household activities and has restricted lumbar motion and chronic back pain. He was assessed as having a 13 per cent impairment. Premier Barry O'Farrell has a simple message for him: No more benefits. When people experience back pain, instead of having their medical benefits paid the New South Wales Government is now telling them to sit in the emergency department at a public hospital and wait.

Many people's injuries do not reach the 20 per cent threshold, and certainly not the 30 per cent threshold. To impose those sorts of thresholds is simply cruel to them and their families. One of the cruellest provisions in this legislation is that, as I said, it will be retrospective. Those people who have been injured for 10 years who cannot work because they are in pain, even though they want to, and who have structured their lives around the benefits they receive to put a bit of money away each week for the mortgage and bills will be smashed by this legislation.

There is absolutely no justification whatsoever for that. Mr Ivan Simic, a lawyer with Taylor Scott, said in his evidence to the select committee:

I think everyone has forgotten that the most important purpose of the scheme is to provide insurance for injured people so their families are not left in family ruin.If we are going to live in a free market society, one of the great things in a free market society is insurance. WorkCover has totally forgotten it is supposed to be an insurer and look after people's families when tragedy strikes. They have just totally forgotten it and lost the plot.

Premier Barry O'Farrell has also lost the plot, as has anyone who votes for this legislation today.

Monday, June 11, 2012

A REPLY TO PAUL SHEEHAN





Paul - you quote some interesting figures which seem to be right from the mouth of Scott Morrison but not from any authoritative source that I can find. Here’s some current stats on those in detention  - In April 2012, the DIAC website states that there were 4329 people in immigration detention facilities and alternative places of detention, including 3528 in immigration detention on the mainland and 801 in immigration detention on Christmas Island. The DIAC website goes on to state that at 30 April 2012, there were 463 children (aged under 18 years) in immigration detention facilities and alternative places of detention. The majority of children in facilities-based detention have been in detention for less than three months. The site states that no children are detained in an immigration detention centre.



1638 people have been approved for a residence determination to live in the community, (DIAC website) but movement of these approved people into the community has been very slow. 3000 people in generous Australian families registered under the Government’s Homestay Program in May 2012. The first 50 refugees to be placed under that program were moved into Australian homes on the 7th June 2012 (Daily Telegraph 8.6.12).Now I don’t have access to budget papers as you seem to do but all of this is downscaling cost in line with Australia's international human rights obligations, a matter that you did not once mention in your article.



At the same time as the Federal Government committed to moving more refugees and asylum seekers out of detention centres, they also decided in April 2012 to reduce payments to people living in community detention from 89% of the lowest Centrelink Payment, to 70% of the lowest Centrelink payment. This will present a challenge to families who have exited detention with their children. In practical terms this will leave a mother and child with around $300 per week with no concessions, to feed and clothe themselves, pay gas, water, electricity and catch public transport to appointments ( Asylum Seeker Resource Centre Email 12.4.12).



What is the current population of Australia Paul. 22,328,800. Google it.  So that makes the people currently in detention .01% of the Australian population. All your fuss for such a tiny proportion of the population! And of the new arrivals , take note that DIAC also tells us that between 2 and 4% of refugees coming to Australia come by boat, each year. The rest arrive by plane. Tony Abbott and Scott Morrison blather on about turning the boats around because they know that this rings bells in the minds of the poorly informed in marginal seats. But they also know that this could cause more drownings and put the lives of service personnel at risk. You seem to have forgotten the revolt by navy service personnel during the Howard Government, revolted by what they were being asked to do.



Wayne Swan was right. Just about all of the people on Nauru were recognised as refugees and came to Australia, some with their mental health damaged for life. But don't let the facts stand in the way of a good story, or your apology for Abbott and Morrison's rampant populism.



Jenny Haines




Sunday, June 10, 2012

UNITE AGAINST ABBOTT


Red News Readers,

It is like this nation is sleepwalking into the nightmare of an Abbott Government. There is still a chance that we could have an Abbott Government this year. The Federal Parliamentary Labor Party needs to get their act together, and changing the leadership is not the only answer. They need to get on the front foot and sell the progressive reform of the last 5 years. The problem with them selling their policy and practice on refugees and asylum seekers is it is such a mash! And a mess! In my view any person who votes left of centre in this country needs to get active in a united push to defeat Abbott. Wake up Australia, an Abbott Government is not for you!


Jenny Haines

Abbott announces tougher asylum policy


June 9, 2012 - 12:49PM

Sydney Morning Herald

AAP

Asylum seekers who are believed to have destroyed their documents before arriving in Australia will have a presumption against refugee status under a coalition government, Tony Abbott says.

As part of three policy "enhancements", which the opposition leader said would immediately be put in place under a coalition government, Mr Abbott said there would be a "strong presumption that illegal boat people who have destroyed their documents not be given refugee status".

Mr Abbott said the government would also ensure that his Immigration Minister "exercise the right" to appeal against affirmative decisions.

"This right has never been exercised under this government," he told reporters on Saturday.

This would ensure that "yeses are checked, not just noes", opposition spokesman for immigration Scott Morrison said.

"Under our current system noes are checked under an appeal process by applicants but yeses never get checked."

Under the third proposal put forward by Mr Abbott, an integrity commissioner would report to the minister every six months on what is happening to the processing success rates.

"What is happening now is that 90 per cent of people who arrive illegally via boat are given successful outcomes."

Mr Abbott said other countries had "heavier rates of rejection" and he wanted to know why this was the case.

The "enhancements" would be on top of the party's current immigration policy, which includes the re-establishment of offshore processing at Nauru, the re-introduction of temporary protection visas and the option of turning boats around.

It is not the first time the opposition has flagged a crackdown on asylum seekers entering Australia without proper documentation.

In April 2010, Mr Morrison said having correct documentation should be a "key requirement" for asylum seekers.

© 2012 AAP


Thursday, May 31, 2012

PRIMROSE OPPOSES ELECTRICITY PRIVATISATION


The Hon. PETER PRIMROSE [9.03 p.m.]: I make a contribution to debate on the Electricity Generator Assets (Authorised Transactions) Bill 2012. My comments will reflect some of the views already stated and will clarify some of the points that need to be reiterated. I opposed the privatisation of electricity assets when the former Labor Government proposed it and I do the same now that the O'Farrell Government has proposed it. On 28 January last year Premier Barry O'Farrell promised to keep the State's electricity generators in public hands. Today we are set to see the ultimate betrayal by the Premier. Premier O'Farrell's plan to sell off the State's electricity assets will send electricity bills soaring for families that are already struggling with the rising cost of living.

Families across New South Wales are already having difficulty meeting the rising cost of heating their homes and Premier O'Farrell's broken promise on electricity privatisation will only make things worse. For example, in South Australia electricity prices increased by more than 30 per cent following privatisation. The O'Farrell Government has already passed on an 18 per cent increase in household electricity bills and New South Wales families cannot take another huge price rise. Premier O'Farrell promised to do everything in his power to reduce the cost of living for families, but there is nothing in this bill to protect families from huge electricity price hikes. If Premier O'Farrell had any idea about the cost of living pressures that New South Wales families are already under, he would keep his election promise and dump this bill.

Contrary to some of the other views that have been expressed, I do not blame the Shooters and Fishers Party for this bill. I do not blame the Christian Democratic Party either. I disagree with many of their policies, but this bill is not theirs. It belongs to the Liberal Party and The Nationals in New South Wales. They own it and they should, and will, continue to own its ramifications for many years into the future. This bill is about trust, honesty and integrity—more accurately, it is about the Government's lack of any of these qualities.

Premier Barry O'Farrell went to the last election promising to raise the bar on ministerial standards and accountability. He promised that he had, "Absolutely no plans to privatise the State's electricity generators". And yet today the O'Farrell Government has this bill to sell off the State's publicly owned electricity generators. Just weeks before the election the then Opposition leader, Barry O'Farrell, made a solemn commitment not to privatise electricity. This has been quoted on a number of occasions this evening, and I will quote it again:


We have absolutely no plans to privatise either the generators or the poles and wires.


That was a statement by Barry O'Farrell in the Lithgow Mercury on 28 January 2011. In Government the Premier has turned his back on his promise and is selling off our publicly owned electricity generators. He is breaking the five conditions on electricity privatisation set down by the Coalition in 2008. The Coalition described these conditions as being fundamental to protecting the public interest. Without going through them at length, I will reiterate what those five conditions are. The first condition states:

All sale and/or lease arrangements be subject to the Auditor-General reporting to Parliament before finalisation of the sale or lease. These arrangements would include, but would not be limited to:

Timing and price; conditions for workers, pensioners and low income earners; and price guarantees for consumers.


But Premier O'Farrell has made no commitment for the sale of the State's generators to be subject to an Auditor-General's review or to parliamentary debate before the transaction is finalised. The second condition states:

Completion, release and adoption of a rural communities impact statement focusing on, among other issues, jobs, prices and service levels.


However, no rural community impact statement has been released for debate on how this privatisation of electricity generators will affect jobs, prices and service levels in rural New South Wales.

The third condition states:


Establishment of an independent oversight body comprising the Auditor-General, a community representative and a financial expert to monitor the use of funds realised from the sale.


What happens in reality? Of course, the funds are proposed to go into the Restart NSW Fund, with amounts being released on a discretionary basis by the Treasurer with no community representation. The fourth condition states in part:

... establishment of a parliamentary oversight committee to guarantee delivery of improvements in clean, green and renewable energy investment resulting from the sale.


What is the reality? No oversight committee has been proposed or established to ensure any proceeds from an asset sale are used to promote green and renewable energy. The fifth condition states:

Retention of the so-called poles and wires businesses in public ownership, and appropriate safety nets for pensioners, low-income families and employees as determined by the Auditor-General.


Once again, what is the reality? This sale has no protection or safety net, no guarantee about the retention of poles and wires in public ownership, no safeguards against price rises for pensioners, no safety net for household and family electricity bills, and no protection for low-income families.

[Interruption]

Given the interjections from members opposite it is obvious that this is stinging. I apologise for that. However, as I said, this is the Government's bill and members opposite will have to wear it for years to come. It is very distressing to me that this is causing concern opposite. As the Hon. Mick Veitch said, many members of The Nationals are obviously concerned about this legislation, and it is obvious from what we are hearing from the Hon. Dr Peter Phelps that even he is concerned about what will happen. The Opposition's major concern is that this will not end here. Premier Barry O'Farrell is reportedly planning to go even further with his electricity asset sales plans. The Daily Telegraph of 30 November 2011 stated:

Mr O'Farrell's office was quietly briefing an angry business community that the Government would go with a plan to sell the poles and wires at the next election—2015.


Premier Barry O'Farrell has broken his promise not to sell off the State's electricity generators. He has thrown away his own guidelines for the sale of any public electricity assets. He said that those guidelines would promote trust in government and that they were fundamental to protecting the public interest. He intends to go further with plans for full privatisation. I oppose this bill.

Monday, May 28, 2012

WHAT AN ABBOTT GOVERNMENT COULD BE LIKE?

Jenny Haines, 27.5.12

In all the argy bargy of recent Australian politics, it is useful to contemplate what Australia would be like now, if a conservative government had been elected in 2007.

There would probably be an unemployment rate in the double figures, a conservative government having engaged in massive sackings in the public sector and having refused to assist unprofitable firms in the private sector. That’s the market!

One or more of the Australian banks, large or small would now be bankrupt, there being no government guarantee of borrowings. That’s the market!

There would have been no stimulus packages which everyone took with glee, spent, then promptly forgot that the government ever gave it to them. Never was the government so popular when those stimulus packages were being handed out. But memories are short in politics.

Schools would not have the facilities that they now have as a result of the schools building program. Yes there were problems!  They were massively overstated.

Higher education would still be staggering along, taking in larger and larger numbers of direct paying overseas students to stay alive.

National health reform would never have commenced. My own profession nursing would be running on larger and larger numbers of lesser skilled workers, because like the Howard Government, the conservative government that succeeded them would not allocate monies to universities to educate sufficient numbers of registered nurses to meet workforce needs, much less the huge shortage of registered nurses nationally.

We would not have had a carbon tax, when just about every other country in the world is moving to address climate change through either a carbon tax or an emissions trading scheme.

We would not have any mining tax and the massive profits from our resources would continue to go out of Australia to overseas countries.

Refugee boats would have been turned around where the conservative government thought they could get away with it. More refugees drowned.  More navy personnel would have been speaking out about their disgust at what they were being asked to do. Hysteria about refugees coming by boat would be a fever pitch again, while the majority of refugees who fly in by plane are ignored. Nauru would have been re-opened and once again we would be hearing and watching on the news, stories of refugees isolated from any chance of fair processing of their legitimate claims, taking desperate measures in their despair.

The gay marriage debate would never have reached even the stage of the permission of civil unions in several states, and there would have been no conscience vote allowed in Federal Parliament on the issue of gay marriage.

This is not to say that there have not been stuff ups, mistakes, and initiatives that have been badly explained to the electorate by the Rudd, and then Gillard Governments. Nor is it to make any excuses for what has happened. But it is useful, as we contemplate a possible Abbott Government in the near future, to think about what that government would look like.

How would an Abbott Government cope with GFC Mark 2, now underway in the world? Most likely they would cut government spending drastically, and let the market sort it out. That would cause a lot of economic, financial and business pain. Unemployment would definitely be in the double figures. Would they guarantee the banks? If not, some of them would be in trouble. Would they hand our stimulus packages? Probably not.

The education sector would face similar disparities in government allocations to those faced under the Howard Government where private schools were able to build new blocks and swimming pools, while public schools held classes in poorly heated demountables. The universities would have to continue to take in larger and large numbers of directly paying overseas students.

The health system would continue to be State based with devolution of decision making to the local level, read, the Coalitions mates, the medical profession. The empowerment of nursing would stop eg through Nurse Practitioners having Medicare rights. At the other end of the nursing profession, the deskilling of workface nurses would continue in deference to employer cost modelling.

The carbon tax would be abolished and lighter imposts placed on big business to monitor their carbon emissions. Tim Flannery’s appointment would be abolished and not replaced.

The mining tax would be abolished, and several government programs would be left without sufficient funding, including further stages of national health reform.

Refugee boats would be turned around. More refugees drown. Relations with Indonesia would reach an all time low as the Indonesians resent the Coalition preaching to them about their responsibilities.

Still no conscience vote allowed on gay marriage in Federal Parliament.

With parts of our media rabidly campaigning against the Gillard Government in every word, in every breath they take, it is worth reviewing the last 5 years and thinking deeply about what we want for Australia’s immediate future. Tony Abbott is a chimera. He is good at selling a message, especially a negative message. But he is not a leader, and he is not the leader this country needs at this crucial time in our history. We need to get this right. It is so important for all of us.

Tuesday, May 22, 2012

ACTION NEEDED ON REFUGEES

An unpublished letter to the SMH, 21.5.12



The Victorian State Conference of the ALP over last weekend unanimously passed a resolution calling on the Federal Government to implement  the policy of the National Conference of the ALP, and the Recommendations of the Joint Select Committee into Australia’s Detention Network re those refugees who are locked up indefinitely because they have received an adverse assessment by ASIO. These people are declared refugees. They cannot be returned to their own country.  There is no right of review or appeal. If they were an Australian citizen there would be a right of appeal. But these people are refugees. We leave them in detention. Some of them suicide. Last week Rajini and her children were, without notice, flown from Melbourne to Sydney and placed in indefinite detention because there is an adverse ASIO finding against them. This is indeed a profound injustice.



The ALP National Conference called for an Independent Security Monitor “ to advise on establishing a mechanism for independent review of the adverse security assessments that ensures procedural fairness while recognising that processes may be required to protect intelligence sources and methodology, (Chapter 9, Paragraph 161, ALP National Platform.)”



Recomendation 27 and 28 of the Joint Select Committee Report calling for review and appeal mechanisms needs to be implemented. Lives depend on it. The mental health of refugees detained indefinitely depend on it.



Jenny Haines


Sunday, May 13, 2012

ABORIGINAL PASSPORTS ISSUED


FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE.......13.5.12

ABORIGINAL PASSPORTS ISSUED TO INDEFINITELY DETAINED TAMILS, DENIED
AUSTRALIAN RESIDENCY ON ‘SECURITY’ GROUNDS

On Monday 14 May, 12.30pm, Aboriginal passports will be issued to two
Tamil men currently held at Villawood Detention Centre who have being
indefinitely detained and denied permanent visas in Australia on ASIO
‘security’ grounds.

The Original Nation Passports - issued by Indigenous Elder Robbie
Thorpe of the Treaty Republic - are being given to the Tamil men by
Indigenous Elder Ray Jackson in a ceremony to be held in front of the
Villawood Immigration Detention Centre on Monday.

Robbie Thorpe stated, “Indigenous people never ceded Sovereignty over
Australia. The Australian Government has no legitimate right to grant
or refuse entry to anyone in this country, let alone lock up people
fleeing war and persecution”.

“We are issuing passports to these men because its what any
reasonable, humane society would do. We expect these men to be
responsive to Traditional Law, and respect the Indigenous customs of
this land. If they do this, which we expect that they will, then they
will be welcome to live amongst us,” said Robbie.

Ray Jackson, President of the Indigenous Social Justice Association,
said that “locking people up doesn’t solve any problems, it only
causes harm. We have seen that time and time again with Indigenous
people, and now the government is making the same mistake with Asylum
Seekers. This has to stop. The Australian Government must stop
imprisoning Indigenous people, and they must stop imprisoning asylum
seekers. I am proud to welcome people in need into our community”.

Ian Rintoul, spokesperson for the Refugee Action Coalition stated,
“These Tamil men are in a heightened state of distress. They have come
from a dangerous and extremely repressive situation in Sri Lanka, and
have been thrust directly into indefinite incarceration for no good
reason.”

“The latest attempted suicide on Friday 11 May by a Tamil that has
been refused security clearance highlights the terrible situation for
the ASIO-negative refugees,” said Ian. “They are condemned to
indefinite detention, without charge or trial. There is no right to
know what evidence ASIO relies on for the negative security finding
and there is no right to review or appeal negative decisions.”

“The Labor government has been sitting on its hands since last
December’s ALP national conference called for the independent security
monitor to review the handling of ASIO refugee assessments,” said Ian
Rintoul.

The indefinite detention of ASIO negative refugees is the subject of a
complaint by ASIO negative refugees in Australian detention to the
Geneva UN High Commission for Human Rights. The Australian government
has been given until July to respond to a complaint. The recent
Parliamentary Report into detention has also called for refugees to
have the same rights of review and appeal for their ASIO assessments
as Australian citizens.

The Original Nations Passport Ceremony will be held at 12.30pm, Monday
the 14th of May, in front of the Villawood Immigration Detention
Centre (Miowera Road entrance). All are welcome to attend.

Media Contact:
Shane Reside, Cross Border Collective, 0400 526 313

For Comment:
Robbie Thorpe, Treaty Republic, 0415 801 170
Ray Jackson, Indigenous Social Justice Association, 0450 651 063
Ian Rintoul, Refugee Action Coalition, 0417 275 713

EXTRACT FROM "THE PEOPLE SMUGGLERS"


THE PEOPLE SMUGGLERS
by Robin De Crespigny, Penguin Books,  2012.

“In determining appropriate sentences I have kept very much in mind that the present offences are by no means in the most serious category of offences contrary to section 232A. In particular, these are not cases of people smuggling where it is intended to introduce non-citizens into this country secretly and with all the dangers of illegal entrants carrying diseases, plant or animal life, which could pose a serious risk to Australia's primary production.

There was no attempt here by the prisoners to hide from the authorities or disguise what they were doing. The offences, whilst serious are correctly described as people trafficking offences rather than people smuggling. Similarly it is significant that none of the prisoners is an organiser. Each played a small but vital role in bringing non-citizens here.”

These are the words of sentencing judges as they sent destitute Indonesian fishermen to prison,  not for any crime at all – these are sentencing notes that have been available for 10 years on the SIEVX.com website and have been presented to the senate in various enquiries over the past 8 years yet now we have  the absurd circumstance of jailing Indonesian children as young as 13 in adult prisons with rapists, thieves and murderers for this non-crime.

In each case it was stated that it was not people smuggling but simply transporting the passengers directly to the authorities as requested by the passengers who had mostly fled Iraq, Iran and Afghanistan and most of whom had been tortured in Indonesia and Malaysia.

The problem is that it is not in any law in the world but Australia anything to do with people smuggling as a new book
”the People Smuggler”  by Robin Decrespigny has clearly shown and as international law dictates.

In 1999 Ruddock supported by Con Sciacca brought in vicious penalties for anyone who assists refugees, including Australians who helped them here.

In many cases going back to 2000 we have been jailing Indonesian children who strangely are all deemed to be 19 according to a now discredited X-ray test. 

It has taken a decade but Hamish McDonald, journalist on the Project, and Mark Plunkett, barrister, have brought to the attention of the public that we are torturing young children in adult maximum security jails for 5 years mandatory terms even though the courts have maintained for over 12 years that they are not people smuggling.

The elephant in the room that is ignored by all the media and discarded by the government in senate committees is the “Smuggling of migrants protocol by land, sea and air” that Ruddock signed in 2000 and ratified through parliament in 2004.

Article 19 of that protocol states:

Nothing in this Protocol shall affect the other rights, obligations and responsibilities of States and individuals under international law, including international humanitarian law and international human rights law and, in particular, where applicable, the 1951 Convention and the 1967 Protocol relating to the Status of Refugees and the principle of nonrefoulement

as contained therein.”

The UNHCR were so concerned they went on to say in the pleniary hearings:

3.      The Protocol against Smuggling, for instance, contains a number of provisions which may impact on smuggled asylum-seekers. The authorization to intercept vessels on the high seas, the obligation to strengthen border controls and to adopt sanctions for commercial carriers, or the commitment to accept the return of smuggled migrants may indeed affect those who seek international protection. A number of comparable provisions of the Protocol against Trafficking may have a similar effect.

4.      During the sessions of the Ad-Hoc Committee, UNHCR therefore emphasized the need to reconcile measures to combat the smuggling of migrants and the trafficking of persons with existing obligations under international refugee law. The Office welcomes the adoption of a saving clause in both Protocols, designed to safeguard the rights of asylum-seekers and refugees under the 1951 Convention and the 1967 Protocol relating to the Status of Refugees, in particular in relation to the principle of non-refoulement.

5.      In addition, UNHCR appreciates the adoption of provisions for the protection of smuggled migrants, such as the obligation of States Parties to take appropriate measures to afford smuggled migrants protection against violence and to take into account the special needs of women and children. The Protocol against Smuggling is also clear in that it does not aim at punishing persons for the mere fact of having been smuggled or at penalizing organizations which assist such persons for purely humanitarian reasons.

Now the result of the government repeatedly ignoring every legal expert and human rights organisation is the country is:

1.   Ali Jasmin, aged 13 on arrival, deemed to be 19 based only on a wrist x-ray taken by a gastroenterologist with no bone x-ray experience and on the test which is itself discredited.

http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2012/05/05/the-tragedy-indonesia-s-international-diplomacy.html

2.       And so it was in February 2010, when a teenager named Ardi headed down to the water. That is his only name. He is 16, he believes, although he has no way of confirming it. Few people here have more than a basic education -- Ardi made it to Year 3 -- which makes reading a luxury, and legal documentation like birth certificates a rarity. He is an orphan, too.


4.   


These children are all in adult prisons in breach of the law that says children should not be jailed but sent home.  None of them had a lawyer prepared to enter their birth certificates in court because they are not nice and modern like ours, none of the judges noticed they were dealing with very young teenage boys, none of the prison guards spoke out, not one person pointed out in the media or courts that they were jailing children as young as 13.

To make it worse instead of using the smuggling protocol to protect those who merely assist refugees in their legal travels to seek asylum the government are keeping these children and hundreds of adults in prisons without charge until all refugee cases are settled.

Why you ask?   Because until the claims have been settled the refugees who come by sea are not deemed to have entered Australia – they then arrive on an Australian jumbo and the Indonesians are charged with smuggling.

AS the Perth Chief Justice stated in March :it is risible to call it people smuggling”.

But the government are so determined to “send a message” now 16 year old Ali Jasmin rots in Albany prison with murderers and rapists.