Sunday, January 11, 2009

LISA'S AGONY: MISCARRIAGE EDICT IGNORED

Red News Readers,

Why are the public and the media surprised at the treatment of miscarrying women? We live in a world now where the economy matters more than society, where compliance with financial constraint matters more than compassion, where health care is delivered in cost units without consideration of human need. So when the stressed staff in emergency departments treat miscarrying women with a lack of compassion, there may be personal and professional issues involved for that staff member, but they are also complying with the policy imperatives of their employers and governments. Ministers and government departments can issue memos reminding staff of the need to be compassionate but it will take a lot more than a simple piece of paper to change behaviours.

Jenny Haines

Lisa's agony: Miscarriage edict ignored

Lisa Carty, Sun Herald.

January 11, 2009

Devastated ... Lisa Watt's three-month-old baby in its sac kept slipping through her fingers and no one at Maitland Hospital was available to help her retrieve it.

A WOMAN has told how she begged hospital staff to find her a bed before she miscarried her baby into a toilet.

In shock, a devastated Lisa Watt, 39, tried to retrieve the foetus before flushing it away.

Her case is one of at least four in which miscarrying women have complained of substandard care at Maitland Hospital, in the Hunter Valley.

Mrs Watt said the case of Jodie Whiteside, who miscarried into a hospital toilet on December 22, showed nothing had changed since she complained about the treatment before she delivered her fourth child, a 12-week-old foetus, in a hospital toilet on May 19.

"I wrote to the hospital three weeks after I lost my baby because I was very unhappy with the way it was handled," she said.

"The maternity unit rang me and told me it could have happened anywhere. I told her I knew that but I couldn't get over the fact that it had happened in the hospital."

Despite an edict that miscarrying women should be given a bed in the maternity unit - an edict issued after Jana Horska miscarried into a Royal North Shore Hospital emergency department toilet in 2007 - Mrs Watt was given only a chair.

"I told the doctor I could feel the baby was just going to gush out," she said.

"She apologised and said there were no beds. She told me to come back in three hours for a scan but I knew the baby was coming and I couldn't wait three hours.

"I went to the toilet and had the baby. He was perfectly formed. I could see him in the little sac. I was trying to get him out. I kept trying but he kept slipping off my hands. I was crying and saying: 'Stay on mummy's hands.'

"For a long time I blamed myself because I just flushed. There was no one there to help me."

After Mrs Watt sent a written complaint three weeks later, a senior hospital staff member phoned and told her the miscarriage could have "happened anywhere", she said.

"I said I could have dealt with it if it had happened anywhere but it didn't; it happened in their hospital. They might have thought it was just a miscarriage but I was losing my child. To me, it wasn't so impersonal as it was to them."

In another case, a woman who miscarried her first baby on December 6 - two weeks before Jodie Whiteside lost her baby - also sent a letter of complaint.

In a written response, Hunter Area emergency services director David Gleadhill said improvements had been made and more were planned.

He apologised, saying the emergency department was not a good place to have a miscarriage, adding that lack of funding meant the hospital's early pregnancy service only opened three mornings a week.

"We would like it to operate seven days a week and we will continue to lobby for this," Dr Gleadhill wrote. "Until that happens, patients attending hospital with a threatened miscarriage will continue to attend the emergency department and may, unfortunately, experience some of the issues encountered by you."

State Opposition health spokeswoman Jillian Skinner described the treatment of miscarrying women at Maitland Hospital as "scandalous".

"I have never been so outraged by a series of revelations as this," she said. "This Government is playing with these people's emotions by promising to fix the problems, then letting them down. Animals get better treatment at a vet."

Yesterday Health Minister John Della Bosca said it was "extremely disappointing that other women have had similar experiences at this hospital".

Guidelines issued after the Horska case had not been followed at Maitland, he said.

"I am very sorry those guidelines, which spell out that women and their families in these situations need to be treated with care and compassion, were not followed," Mr Della Bosca said.

"Clearly we need to reissue them and ensure frontline doctors and nurses understand them and are supported to implement them."

He said he would visit Maitland Hospital later this month

Saturday, January 10, 2009

REPORTS OF ISRAELI MASSACRE

30 dead after Israel shells civilian safe-house: witnesses

The United Nations has cited witnesses saying Israeli forces moved about 110 Palestinians into a house, told them to stay inside, and later shelled it repeatedly, killing about 30 people.

The Israeli army said it had no knowledge of such an incident but was investigating.

The UN report said that "according to several testimonies, on January 4, Israeli foot soldiers evacuated approximately 110 Palestinians into a single-residence house in Zeitun (half of whom were children) warning them to stay indoors. Twenty-four hours later, Israeli forces shelled the home repeatedly, killing approximately 30."

The UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) called the events in the Gaza City neighbourhood "one of the gravest incidents since the beginning of operations" by Israeli forces in Gaza on December 27.

"Those who survived and were able walked two kilometres to Salah Ed Din road before being transported to hospital in civilian vehicles. Three children, the youngest of whom was five months old, died upon arrival at the hospital," OCHA said.

Israeli military spokeswoman Avital Leibovich said: "From initial checking, we don't have knowledge of this incident. We started an inquiry but we still don't know about it."
Rescuers from the International Committee of the Red Cross and the Palestinian Red Crescent Society were only able to reach the area on Wednesday after waiting four days for Israel to allow them safe passage.

The Israel B'Tselem human rights group quoted a resident giving details of the alleged incident over the telephone but stressed it was unable to independently verify the account.
Meysa Fawzi al Samuni, 19, said soldiers forced her and dozens of others to move into the warehouse-like home of another resident.

Two men who left the house to pick up a relative were struck by "a missile or a shell," she said.

"My husband went over to them to help, and then a shell or missile was fired onto the roof of the warehouse. Based on the intensity of the strike, I think it was a missile from an F-16," B'Tselem quoted Ms Samuni, the mother of a small baby, as saying.

"After the smoke and dust cleared a bit, I looked around and saw 20-30 people who were dead, and about 20 who were wounded."

She eventually managed to leave and find an ambulance. "As far as I know, the dead and wounded who were under the ruins are still there," she was quoted as saying.

Aid operations restricted

Israel insists it is doing all it can to avert civilian casualties and protect humanitarian operations but has faced mounting international criticism after dozens of people were killed when troops fired at a school, and at least one person died after an aid convoy was attacked.

The International Committee of the Red Cross is temporarily restricting its Gaza operations to the territory's main city after one person was lightly wounded when one of its vehicles escorting an ambulance convoy was hit, apparently by Israeli forces, an ICRC spokeswoman said.
UNRWA, the main UN agency in Gaza which provides food aid to half the territory's 1.5 million people, said it had suspended its operations after tank shells hit a UN-flagged humanitarian convoy on Thursday, killing at least one person.

On Tuesday, 43 people were killed when an Israeli strike hit an UNRWA school serving as an emergency shelter.

The UN Security Council late on Thursday adopted a resolution calling for an immediate ceasefire leading to a "full withdrawal" of Israeli troops, and condemning "all violence and hostilities directed against civilians and all acts of terrorism."

Palestinian medics said that at least 782 Palestinians have been killed in the two-week offensive which Israel says targets the Hamas rulers of Gaza and aims at halting the daily volleys of rocket fire into Israel.

- AFP

© http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2009/01/09/2462821.htm?section=justin


Maqsood A K Alshams
Project Director
Asia Pacific Human Rights Institute

CASUALTIES OF A SICK SYSTEM

Red News Readers,

This is what happens when clinicians are disempowered and the managerial budgetary imperative takes priority because managers are trying to please NSW Health first, and not thinking through the effect on standards of patient care. It happens all the time in the current health system and reflects wrong priorities. If the health system is to be managed by accountants and business managers, there has to be greater respect and credit given to the concerns of clinical staff. After all, it is all about standards of patient care and satisfaction, not the budget bottom line. Or am I just being old fashioned again?

Jenny Haines

Casualties of a sick system

Julie Robotham Medical Editor, smh

January 10, 2009

Latest related coverage
Bloodied woman sent to hospital toilet to miscarry
'She was as healthy as an ox' but the system let her down

A WESTMEAD Hospital scheme designed to slash costs and improve performance statistics by getting patients out of ambulances more quickly contributed to the deaths of two patients, who received sub-standard care in the emergency department, internal investigations claim.

Patients were placed on trolley beds in a corridor, under the care of a nurse and without supervision by a doctor or even basic resuscitation equipment, under the scheme, which continued for seven months after the first death and despite the written objections of the hospital's emergency chief.

Internal investigations into the deaths of a 64-year-old man in February 2007, and of 85-year-old Mary Redfern in October the same year, pointed to inherent dangers in the so-called Nurse Ambulance Release Team (NART) arrangements as significant contributors to both.

A report into the death of the man - admitted with a lung infection, low blood pressure and low oxygen levels - concluded, "the geographical location of NART beds and the absence of allocated [doctors] to the NART beds were a contributory factor".

It recommended the relocation of the release team to "a defined clinical space", with emergency equipment and medical supervision.

But the hospital's administration did not act on the advice until Mrs Redfern's death, which occurred after nurses missed the seriousness of her falling blood pressure. The hospital's investigation again blamed the release team initiative in part, concluding, "There is an inability to [recognise] critical illness … in the NART area."

Internal emails, seen by the Herald, show hospital management rejected a demand by the director of emergency medicine, Matthew Vukasovic, for the immediate cessation of the release team system six weeks before Mrs Redfern's death.

"I feel that the minimal advantages that are obtained from offloading patients on to a NART trolley are overshadowed by the patient safety issues," Dr Vukasovic wrote on September 12 to Maureen Berry, the director of clinical operations for a group of western Sydney hospitals including Westmead.

Ms Berry responded by forbidding Dr Vukasovic from ending the release team arrangements without her permission, saying this would inflate costs and off-stretcher times and would not ease crowding in the corridor - which she said would still be occupied by ambulance trolley teams.

The initiative was finally ended days after Mrs Redfern's death.

Under the scheme, patients arriving at a crowded emergency department could be transferred into the care of a registered nurse - typically a part-time or casual employee on an extra shift - who worked without formal supervision by a doctor, allowing the ambulance team to return to the road.

This replaced a more expensive measure in which ambulance paramedics, paid overtime rates, were based at the emergency department to offload ambulance patients.

An internal memo shows the hospital expected to save more than $200,000 a year by having nurses take charge of patients - half the $400,000 cost of ambulance officers managing the equivalent service.

According to a 2006 synopsis of the policy, written by hospital administrators when they entered it for a health-care industry award, the proportion of people waiting longer than 30 minutes to be off-loaded from an ambulance fell from 30 per cent to about 10 per cent - the NSW Health Department benchmark - immediately after its introduction.

In a written response to questions, a spokeswoman for Sydney West Area Health Service, which administers Westmead Hospital, said the initiative was intended as "a way of improving patient care by providing a better, safer and cheaper alternative [to hospital-based ambulance officers]".

Despite the damning conclusions of the internal reports, she said the two deaths were due to "multiple factors but not a direct result of the NART model of care".

Saturday, January 03, 2009

CAMPBELLTOWN AGAIN, AND AGAIN

John Haywood, son Johnny ask why mother, wife, Marie died

By Rhett Watson, State Political Reporter, Daily Telegraph

January 03, 2009 12:00am

JOHN Haywood will spend this morning in a church chapel watching a video of the life he shared with his wife of 25 years, Marie.

He and his 15-year-old son Johnny won't speak at her funeral - the only word they can think of at the moment is "why."

Why was she told she was well enough to leave Campbelltown Hospital despite having pneumonia she contracted in there.

"My wife went into Campbelltown Hospital two days before Christmas Day for a routine operation and now she is dead," Mr Haywood said yesterday.

"She wasn't going in there to die.

"They made her sick and they should have made her better. She was only 43."

Her death has sparked a full investigation into events leading to her death on Monday.

Mrs Haywood went into hospital to have fluid removed from her stomach; a minor operation done under local anaesthetic. By Christmas Day she was seriously ill with pneumonia as well but

Mr Haywood said a specialist, without actually seeing her, decided she was well enough to go home.

"One of the staff there told Marie's sister they didn't have a lot of staff on anyway and she'd probably get better care at home," Mr Haywood said. "She didn't want to go home because she knew was still too unwell."

By December 27 Mrs Haywood could not breathe and was rushed back to Campbelltown Hospital where she was immediately put in intensive care. She died on Monday.

Mr Haywood believes the State Government's penny-pinching in health contributed, in a large way, to her death.

"Most of the beds and rooms were closed off when we were in there," he said.

"We want to know whether it was the system that fell down or the people."

The hospital and state Government argue there was enough staff and would not say more as the matter was being investigated.

PUBLIC VS PRIVATE: THE PAINFUL TRUTH ABOUT CHILDBIRTH

January 3, 2009

Latest related coverage:

Aged-care companies boycott bed offer
Patient data could show medicines danger
Drugs do a vanishing act

There are wide discrepancies in rates of intervention for births, writes Julie Robotham, smh.

THERE was never any question in Leanne Ortika's mind that she would have an epidural for pain relief when she delivered her first child.

"I decided that from the moment I got pregnant," said Mrs Ortika, 28, whose daughter Abigail is now six months old. "I didn't want to feel any pain."

Luckily for her, she was in the right place. At Sutherland's Kareena Private Hospital, where Abigail was born, only 4 per cent of mothers do without pain relief - one of the lowest rates in NSW, but on a par with most other private hospitals - as doctors adhere to the powerful maxim of patient choice.

At Auburn Hospital, where a state high of 23 per cent of women have no pain relief, Entessar Chami felt her choices were respected, too.

A few puffs of nitrous oxide at the height of her labour got the 27-year-old through the swift birth on December 17 of Shadi, her second child, and she felt relieved and grateful.

Throughout her previous pregnancy, with daughter Layla, now two, a caesarean section had been a possibility because of a low-lying placenta that shifted just in time for a vaginal birth. Mrs Chami had been horrified by "the thought of them cutting my stomach open to deliver a baby when I could just push it out naturally".

A national review of birth services and the roles of doctors and midwives in bringing children into the world has highlighted wide discrepancies in rates of birth intervention across NSW, especially between the public and private systems.

Caesarean births reached 46 per cent at Kareena and exceeded 40 per cent at most other private hospitals, where women are usually assisted by the same private obstetrician they have been seeing throughout their pregnancy, according to 2005 figures - the most recent available.

Between one-quarter and one-third of women in most private hospitals have an episiotomy - a surgical cut to the vagina to widen it for delivery, compared with about 10 per cent in the public sector. Forceps or vacuum deliveries are about 15 per cent of all births in private hospitals, well above the 10 per cent state average.

And while differences in the age and health of pregnant women are behind some of the disparity, experts say this is not enough to explain it all. Even young, healthy women such as Mrs Ortika and Mrs Chami may have very different perspectives on how they wish to give birth, and their demands - and hospitals' willingness to accede to them - are at the heart of the issue.

Ted Weaver, the president of the Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists, said having an epidural anaesthetic - more widely available in the private than the public system - increased the chance a woman would not be able to push out her baby independently.

If the drug blocked all sensation, so the woman had no urge to push, "there's a pretty high chance - more than 50 per cent - she'll end up with [a vacuum extraction or forceps delivery]", he said.

Then, if forceps were used, "most women would end up with an episiotomy", Dr Weaver said. It was not clear whether women knew about the link between these interventions.

But Dr Weaver said there was "also a cascade of non-intervention - the idea that you leave everything alone and it'll be all right. That model has many flaws in it. You can be criticised for not doing things, too."

In the college's submission to the maternity review, being undertaken by the Commonwealth Chief Nurse and Midwifery Officer, Rosemary Bryant, it said reasons for the high private caesarean rate included the older age of mothers with health insurance, and the lack of emergency caesarean facilities at many private hospitals, which may persuade doctors to schedule the surgery instead of waiting to see how the birth progresses. As well, it said, mothers who chose private care appeared less tolerant of any risk to the foetus.

But the submission conceded there were "particular practitioners in the private sector who have a caesarean section rates in excess of 60 per cent. [The college] views these rates with concern."

In an individual submission, David Ellwood, a professor of obstetrics and gynaecology at the Australian National University Medical School, said caesarean rates were, "inappropriately high" in the private sector, and he was concerned "that once we reach a rate of … 35 to 40 per cent we could reach a tipping point from which the rate will accelerate more rapidly".

Recent research showed caesareans increased risks to both mother and baby in a first pregnancy, and more so in subsequent pregnancies.

Andrew Zuschmann, who delivers babies at Kareena, said there was a high demand there for "maternal choice caesarean section" without medical need.

"I'm a strong advocate of patient choice," he said. "I see my job as a facilitator and provider of information. I think women in this area are highly educated and highly informed."

But despite this, said Dr Zuschmann, "nobody's asked me my personal caesarean section rate, ever."

Indra Wijetunga, director of clinical services at Kareena, declined to comment on the hospital's birth intervention rate, saying, "these are choices between patients and doctors".

Paul Mackey, the director of policy and research at the Australian Private Hospitals Association, said doctors worked as contractors in private hospitals, which typically did not set clinical policies, except to ensure doctors were appropriately qualified. But Mr Mackey said he hoped the maternity review would offer "greater understanding as to why there is this variance".

Fiona Hammond, Auburn Hospital's clinical midwifery specialist, said only women whose pregnancy was judged low-risk were attended there. But the low intervention rate was also attributable to practices within the unit. "We try to encourage labour in an upright position," she said, which helped it to progress faster.

"Midwives do lead the care and consult with obstetricians rather than being told what to do. We try not to invoke a sickness model around us. We try to encourage women that it is a normal part of life."

Friday, January 02, 2009

CUBA: 50 YEARS OF REVOLUTION

Communist Cuba celebrates 50 years of Revolution

January 2, 2009 - 10:27AM, smh

Communist Cuba marked the 50th anniversary of its Revolution Thursday faced with an uncertain future, its iconic, ailing leader Fidel Castro withdrawn from power and the economy in dire straits.

President Raul Castro led official ceremonies in Santiago de Cuba, the city from where his brother Fidel proclaimed victory over US-backed dictator Fulgencio Batista in 1959 after 25 months of fighting in the Sierra Maestra mountains.

In an olive green army uniform, Raul, 77, -- who officially took over from 82-year-old Fidel last February -- received an ovation, along with other party leaders, from 3,000 guests at the start of Thursday evening's festivities.

Fidel, who has not appeared in public since undergoing major surgery almost two and a half years ago, sent a brief, signed greeting to the Cuban people in Granma, the communist party newspaper.

But his image dominated giant banners and billboards amid the somber celebrations, with the island hard hit by the economic crisis and the aftermath of three hurricanes this year that left some 10 billion US dollars in damage.

"Let's not kid ourselves by believing that from here on, it's all going to be easy. Maybe from here on, it's going to be more difficult," Raul Castro cautioned late Wednesday.

Despite hardships he blamed on 46-year-old US sanctions, the president stressed: "this hasn't been a failure, not even under these conditions. It has been a constant fight."

The celebrations coincide with recent moves by Cuba to broaden its international ties, and the presidents of China and Russia, Hu Jintao and Dmitry Medvedev respectively, sent congratulatory messages Thursday.

Leftist Latin American leaders heaped praise on Cuba's past half-century.

Oil-rich Venezuela, Cuba's main business partner, held a special ceremony to commemorate the anniversary.

Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez called the Cuban Revolution "the mother of all the revolutions going on in Latin America and the Caribbean."

Nicaraguan President Daniel Ortega called the 50th anniversary a "landmark" in Latin American history and Bolivian President Evo Morales lauded the island and its people.

"Fifty years ago the Cuban people freed themselves from US rule. For that, Cuba, its people and its commanders are symbols of the liberation of the people of the world," Morales said.

After years of economic embargo and hardline US efforts to isolate the island, Havana now faces rare potential for change with US president-elect Barack Obama, who has voiced willingness to communicate unconditionally with world leaders.

Cuba's Revolution -- led by a 32-year-old Fidel Castro and legendary Argentine guerilla Ernesto "Che" Guevara -- took on Marxist overtones in May 1961, one month after the attempted invasion of the Bay of Pigs by CIA-backed Cuban exiles.

Former US president John F. Kennedy declared the embargo in February 1962, before the Soviet missile crisis, which took the world to the brink of nuclear war.

The two nations, separated by just 90 miles (145 kilometers) of water, have remained bitter political foes.

A White House spokesman in Texas Wednesday said Washington "will continue to seek freedom" for the people of Cuba.

But Obama, who takes power January 20, has promised to ease some rules limiting travel by and remittances from Cuban-Americans; Raul Castro repeatedly has said he is ready for talks without "carrot or stick" with Obama.

The Cuban president has also promised "structural reforms" -- a departure from his older brother and leading members of the communist old guard.

But the global economic crisis may impact the pledged changes, as the president signaled in July when he announced greater government control of revenues and tighter management of agriculture.

The Caribbean island is still officially in the Special Period in Peacetime, an extended period of economic crisis that began in 1991 after the collapse of its former main benefactor, the Soviet Union.

And life is tough for most of Cuba's 11.2 million people, who earn an average of 20 US dollars per month and survive tangled in a parallel economy.

"The Revolution has given us a lot. I'm communist but I wish there were changes in the economy, that's where the problem is," said 65-year-old Pedro at Thursday's celebrations.

"The situation is really bad. Salaries are not enough to live off. They've made a lot of mistakes," said Joel Romero, a 41-year-old who gave up his job as a health worker to rear pigs.

Branded US puppets by Havana, Cuban dissidents say there are 219 "political prisoners" on the island.

During his decades in power, Fidel Castro expropriated foreign companies, jailed political enemies and drove well over a million Cubans into exile.

But he also introduced historic reforms, including major education and health care access advances.

© 2009 AFPThis story is sourced direct from an overseas news agency as an additional service to readers. Spelling follows North American usage, along with foreign currency

WAITING TIMES RISING

Red News Readers,

Thirty plus years experience as a nurse in the health system tells me that you have to look at causes behind the rising waiting times in emergency departments. Access block is the main problem, too few beds for too many people, too few staff, especially experienced staff, for the beds that are open. The NSW health system has been over-rationalised, and now there is an reluctance or an inability to open more beds.

But why are there too many people in emergency departments? I think it is because emergency departments are the most accessible and affordable portal into the health system. It is a very fortunate citizen these days who can find a GP who bulk bills. Medical specialist fees are skyrocketing. GPs often only open in daylight hours, and do not home visit, unless they have an after hours locum service, most of whom charge a fortune. There is almost nowhere else to go if you have a dental emergency after hours. There are many citizens who see emergency departments as the place to present with all sorts of health problems which could be dealt with by a GP, if they could get in to see a GP. I have heard of patients ringing GPs for a semi urgent matter and been told the waiting list is 4 weeks. So they present at emergency department. The problem is access to the health system, not just access to emergency departments.

Jenny Haines

Hospitals struggle with emergencies

Kate Benson Medical Reporter, smh

January 2, 2009

ALMOST one in three people are waiting more than eight hours in emergency departments for a bed, the highest in 18 months, but doctors say the true figures are much worse as hospitals struggle with a surge in the number of patients and a lack of staff, beds and funding.

NSW Health figures, released yesterday after the Opposition health spokeswoman, Jillian Skinner, submitted a freedom of information request, show that 29 per cent of people are waiting more than eight hours for a bed, known as access block, up from 19 per cent six months ago, but the figures failed to reveal that some patients could wait up to five days, the president of the Australasian College of Emergency Medicine, Sally McCarthy, said yesterday.

"A patient is only counted when they have been waiting for eight hours or more for a bed, but you can have people waiting for days and days in the emergency department," she said.

"There are plenty of cases where management will move a person out of the department when they have been waiting for 7½ hours to avoid them being counted as an access block statistic, while someone who has been waiting more than eight hours could be overlooked and left for days because they have already been counted anyway."

About 17 per cent of people who present with imminently life-threatening conditions (triage 2 category) are not being seen within the required 10 minutes and 32 per cent of those with potentially life-threatening conditions (category 3) are not being seen within the necessary 30 minutes, up from 15 per cent and 30 per cent 18 months ago. The number of patients not being seen on time in categories four and five remain the same.

There were 153,897 people seen in emergency departments between June and September, up from 137,117 in June 2007, with most of the increase in the middle and lower triage categories.

"Bed numbers have not changed in 10 years but we are seeing about 40 per cent more patients through our emergency departments," Dr McCarthy said.

"It is very bad for the proper functioning of any emergency department because once we have 10 per cent of patients not being moved out to a bed, it starts to create problems. We have no space to see new cases, ambulances are delayed, patients get poor treatment and it has been well documented that mortality rates go up."

Mrs Skinner said: "They are the worst emergency department figures I have seen in my 13 years in the job. No wonder the Government tried to hide them. The Garling inquiry was told that stressed ED staff need more doctors, experienced nurses and beds in wards but nothing has been done."

Thursday, January 01, 2009

AUSTRALIAN JEWISH STATEMENT ON GAZA

The following statement was issued by the Executive of the Australian Jewish Democratic Society on 30 December. A truncated version of it was published in the Sydney Morning Herald under Steve Brook’s name.

Many Israelis want their government to prevent the renewed and frightening rocket attacks from Gaza on Israeli southern towns. For various reasons, the government feels compelled to respond. This kind of scenario has played out many times in the past. Israel exacts an enormous price from the Palestinians in the blood of many innocent bystanders in exchange for the rocket attacks.

Unless international action prevents it, there will be a new cycle of violence. Israel has chosen a bloody and dangerous path, the outcome of which may well be to Israel's political and security detriment, just as happened two years ago with its incursion into Lebanon. There will be many innocent dead, but no resolution.

It has been so inevitable, and also so pointless. Israel has virtually imprisoned more than a million Palestinians in Gaza under conditions that have created immense deprivation and desperation. It refuses to negotiate with their leaders, although it did manage to get a ceasefire some six months ago, which was needlessly broken by Israel because of a tunnel.

We don't have a simple solution. The road back to sanity will be a long one. But every time Israel demonstrates its overwhelming military superiority, every time Israel pulls the noose around Gaza tighter, the problem becomes even more intractable. Long term, a resolution can only come through a readiness to talk, seeking a compromise that both sides can live with. Israel holds most of the cards. It can afford to be magnanimous to break the cycle of violence. Accepting a ceasefire by both sides would be a useful first step.

SMH

Bloody cost of Israel repeating past mistakes

Israelis want their government to take action against the rocket attacks from Gaza. But it is exacting an enormous price from the Palestinians in the blood of many innocent bystanders.

Unless international action prevents it, there will be a new cycle of violence. Israel has chosen a bloody and dangerous path, the outcome of which may well be to its political and security detriment, just as happened two years ago with its incursion into Lebanon.
It has been so inevitable, and so pointless. Israel has virtually imprisoned more than a million Palestinians in Gaza under conditions that have created immense deprivation and desperation. It refuses to negotiate with their leaders, although it did manage to get a ceasefire some six months ago, which was needlessly broken by Israel.

We don't have a simple solution. The road back to sanity will be a long one. But every time Israel demonstrates its overwhelming military superiority, every time Israel pulls the noose around Gaza tighter, the problem becomes even more intractable.

Steve Brook Australian Jewish Democratic Society, Melbourne

NO ANTIBIOTICS IN GAZA

No antibiotics to halt slow death as hospitals overwhelmed

Sudarsan Raghavan and Islam Abdel Kareem in Jerusalem, smh

January 1, 2009

Latest related coverage

Jason Koutsoukis:

Land invasion likely as French ceasefire bid stalls
Hamas ties with Egypt strained to breaking point
Lebanon war haunts US response to conflict

Other related coverage

Graduation joy turns to carnage

RAWIYA AYAD lay in a bed on the ground floor of Gaza City's Shifa Hospital, connected to a respirator. A bandage covered her head and dried blood was still on her face. Shrapnel from an Israeli air strike was embedded in her brain, poisoning her blood. She was in a coma.

The hospital had no antibiotics to prevent her slow death. There was a shortage of electricity, too. So if the generator malfunctioned, Ayad's respirator would shut down and she could be dead within two hours.

There were no skilled neurosurgeons. The eight-hour drive to get treatment in Egypt could kill her. Because of the cordon around the Gaza Strip, it was unclear whether she could make it to medical care in Israel.

"I have a feeling there's no way I can help her," Fawzi Nabulsia, 57, director of the intensive care unit, said.

Shifa Hospital has once again become the ground zero of both Palestinian suffering and hope.

The doctors there are accustomed to the violence in the region, having provided treatment through two intifadas, or uprisings against Israel. But nothing had prepared them for the chaos that began on Saturday when Israel launched its air offensive.

"I saw the first intifada and second intifada, but what I saw this time I have never seen in my life," Dr Nabulsia said.

"What we suffered in Shifa, entire countries could not bear. All the victims of Gaza, it seemed, came to this hospital." On Tuesday evening, Shifa Hospital officials said they had treated 73 women and 150 children for injuries during the preceding 24 hours. Nine women and 22 children had died, Hassan Khalaf, a doctor and senior official at the hospital, said.

For the past four days, humanitarian groups have been sounding the alarm about growing shortages of medicine, food and other necessities.

On Tuesday, Israel began to allow some shipments of humanitarian aid into the densely populated area of 1.5 million people. Some of the medicines reached Shifa, but doctors said they required more assistance.

"We are in a very dire situation," Dr Khalaf said. Ten minutes after Israel attacked on Saturday, scores of patients began to flood into Shifa.

Only three doctors were on duty, Ayman al-Sahabani recalled. "We were not prepared for a day like this."

In hours, the scores became hundreds. More doctors arrived. But still the surgeons and operating rooms were insufficient.

"Many people died while they were waiting to enter the operating rooms. Some died in the lobby of the hospital waiting to enter the reception area," Hussein Ashor, the hospital's director, said.

"There were not enough beds, so we pulled out the curtains and lay them on the ground, and we put patients on the curtains. The floor of the reception was covered with blood."

Some doctors performed operations in the hospital corridors, forced to use only local anaesthetic and unsterilised equipment, Hamid Rashid, an orthopaedic surgeon, said.

"It was like a natural disaster," he said. "I was looking at the faces of patients. I feared I would find among them one of my sons or relatives."

On Sunday men believed to be Hamas fighters grabbed a patient, accusing him of being an Israeli collaborator. The patient had been inside a prison that was hit by a missile. The gunmen shot him dead. "They took revenge," Dr Khalaf said.

The Washington Post

Wednesday, December 31, 2008

IF GAZA FALLS....

If Gaza falls . . .

Sara Roy . London Review of Books

Israel’s siege of Gaza began on 5 November, the day after an Israeli attack inside the strip, no doubt designed finally to undermine the truce between Israel and Hamas established last June. Although both sides had violated the agreement before, this incursion was on a different scale.

Hamas responded by firing rockets into Israel and the violence has not abated since then.

Israel’s siege has two fundamental goals. One is to ensure that the Palestinians there are seen merely as a humanitarian problem, beggars who have no political identity and therefore can have no political claims. The second is to foist Gaza onto Egypt. That is why the Israelis tolerate the hundreds of tunnels between Gaza and Egypt around which an informal but increasingly regulated commercial sector has begun to form. The overwhelming majority of Gazans are impoverished and officially 49.1 per cent are unemployed. In fact the prospect of steady employment is rapidly disappearing for the majority of the population.

On 5 November the Israeli government sealed all the ways into and out of Gaza. Food, medicine, fuel, parts for water and sanitation systems, fertiliser, plastic sheeting, phones, paper, glue, shoes and even teacups are no longer getting through in sufficient quantities or at all. According to Oxfam only 137 trucks of food were allowed into Gaza in November. This means that an average of 4.6 trucks per day entered the strip compared to an average of 123 in October this year and 564 in December 2005. The two main food providers in Gaza are the UN Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA) and the World Food Programme (WFP). UNRWA alone feeds approximately 750,000 people in Gaza, and requires 15 trucks of food daily to do so. Between 5 November and 30 November, only 23 trucks arrived, around 6 per cent of the total needed; during the week of 30 November it received 12 trucks, or 11 per cent of what was required. There were three days in November when UNRWA ran out of food, with the result that on each of these days 20,000 people were unable to receive their scheduled supply. According to John Ging, the director of UNRWA in Gaza, most of the people who get food aid are entirely dependent on it. On 18 December UNRWA suspended all food distribution for both emergency and regular programmes because of the blockade.

The WFP has had similar problems, sending only 35 trucks out of the 190 it had scheduled to cover Gazans’ needs until the start of February (six more were allowed in between 30 November and 6 December). Not only that: the WFP has to pay to store food that isn’t being sent to Gaza. This cost $215,000 in November alone. If the siege continues, the WFP will have to pay an extra $150,000 for storage in December, money that will be used not to support Palestinians but to benefit Israeli business.

The majority of commercial bakeries in Gaza – 30 out of 47 – have had to close because they have run out of cooking gas. People are using any fuel they can find to cook with. As the UN Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO) has made clear, cooking-gas canisters are necessary for generating the warmth to incubate broiler chicks. Shortages of gas and animal feed have forced commercial producers to smother hundreds of thousands of chicks. By April, according to the FAO, there will be no poultry there at all: 70 per cent of Gazans rely on chicken as a major source of protein.

Banks, suffering from Israeli restrictions on the transfer of banknotes into the territory were forced to close on 4 December. A sign on the door of one read: ‘Due to the decision of the Palestinian Finance Authority, the bank will be closed today Thursday, 4.12.2008, because of the unavailability of cash money, and the bank will be reopened once the cash money is available.’
The World Bank has warned that Gaza’s banking system could collapse if these restrictions continue. All cash for work programmes has been stopped and on 19 November UNRWA suspended its cash assistance programme to the most needy. It also ceased production of textbooks because there is no paper, ink or glue in Gaza. This will affect 200,000 students returning to school in the new year. On 11 December, the Israeli defence minister, Ehud Barak, sent $25 million following an appeal from the Palestinian prime minister, Salaam Fayad, the first infusion of its kind since October. It won’t even cover a month’s salary for Gaza’s 77,000 civil servants.

On 13 November production at Gaza’s only power station was suspended and the turbines shut down because it had run out of industrial diesel. This in turn caused the two turbine batteries to run down, and they failed to start up again when fuel was received some ten days later. About a hundred spare parts ordered for the turbines have been sitting in the port of Ashdod in Israel for the last eight months, waiting for the Israeli authorities to let them through customs. Now Israel has started to auction these parts because they have been in customs for more than 45 days.

The proceeds are being held in Israeli accounts.

During the week of 30 November, 394,000 litres of industrial diesel were allowed in for the power plant: approximately 18 per cent of the weekly minimum that Israel is legally obliged to allow in. It was enough for one turbine to run for two days before the plant was shut down again.

The Gaza Electricity Distribution Company said that most of the Gaza Strip will be without electricity for between four and 12 hours a day. At any given time during these outages, over 65,000 people have no electricity.

No other diesel fuel (for standby generators and transport) was delivered during that week, no petrol (which has been kept out since early November) or cooking gas. Gaza’s hospitals are apparently relying on diesel and gas smuggled from Egypt via the tunnels; these supplies are said to be administered and taxed by Hamas. Even so, two of Gaza’s hospitals have been out of cooking gas since the week of 23 November.

Adding to the problems caused by the siege are those created by the political divisions between the Palestinian Authority in the West Bank and the Hamas Authority in Gaza. For example, Gaza’s Coastal Municipalities Water Utility (CMWU), which is not controlled by Hamas, is supposed to receive funds from the World Bank via the Palestinian Water Authority (PWA) in Ramallah to pay for fuel to run the pumps for Gaza’s sewage system. Since June, the PWA has refused to hand over those funds, perhaps because it feels that a functioning sewage system would benefit Hamas. I don’t know whether the World Bank has attempted to intervene, but meanwhile UNRWA is providing the fuel, although they have no budget for it. The CMWU has also asked Israel’s permission to import 200 tons of chlorine, but by the end of November it had received only 18 tons – enough for one week of chlorinated water. By mid-December Gaza City and the north of Gaza had access to water only six hours every three days.

According to the World Health Organisation, the political divisions between Gaza and the West Bank are also having a serious impact on drug stocks in Gaza. The West Bank Ministry of Health (MOH) is responsible for procuring and delivering most of the pharmaceuticals and medical disposables used in Gaza. But stocks are at dangerously low levels. Throughout November the MOH West Bank was turning shipments away because it had no warehouse space, yet it wasn’t sending supplies on to Gaza in adequate quantities. During the week of 30 November, one truck carrying drugs and medical supplies from the MOH in Ramallah entered Gaza, the first delivery since early September.

The breakdown of an entire society is happening in front of us, but there is little international response beyond UN warnings which are ignored. The European Union announced recently that it wanted to strengthen its relationship with Israel while the Israeli leadership openly calls for a large-scale invasion of the Gaza Strip and continues its economic stranglehold over the territory with, it appears, the not-so-tacit support of the Palestinian Authority in Ramallah – which has been co-operating with Israel on a number of measures. On 19 December Hamas officially ended its truce with Israel, which Israel said it wanted to renew, because of Israel’s failure to ease the blockade.

How can keeping food and medicine from the people of Gaza protect the people of Israel? How can the impoverishment and suffering of Gaza’s children – more than 50 per cent of the population – benefit anyone? International law as well as human decency demands their protection. If Gaza falls, the West Bank will be next.

Sara Roy teaches at Harvard’s Center for Middle Eastern Studies and is the author of Failing Peace: Gaza and the Palestinian-Israeli Conflict.

EMBATTLED HOSPITAL SHUFFLES MIDWIVES

Red News Readers,

The public needs to understand that this is the stupidity that nurses and midwives have to put up with on a daily basis. Managers think they are being so clever making moves like this but all it does is frustrate the nursing and midwifery staff and leave patients at risk of an error. Let nurses be nurses and midwives be midwives, for goodness sake and let the public get the best standard of care available.

Jenny Haines

Embattled hospital shuffles midwives

Kate Benson Medical Reporter, smh

December 31, 2008

MIDWIVES at the beleaguered Blue Mountains hospital are being forced to work on general wards because several surgical nurses have been given shifts in the maternity unit while the operating theatres are closed for three weeks.

The bizarre move has angered staff and comes a day after the Herald reported that two women in the late stages of labour were turned away from the maternity unit over Christmas because an obstetrician was not available to help them. One gave birth in an ambulance on the roadside, while the other, seven weeks' premature, was rushed to Royal Prince Alfred Hospital, 90 minutes away, but was diverted to Westmead Hospital because the birth was imminent. The baby, born minutes later, is still in intensive care.

In September, the State Government promised to keep the maternity unit open after the community campaigned against its closure. Almost 300 babies have been delivered there this year but midwives and residents say the unit is often closed at short notice due to a lack of staff and can be shut for up to a week at a time, forcing women to Nepean Hospital, 45 minutes away.

Now staff are angry that midwives, many of whom have studied at university for 4½ years, are being sent to other wards while staff not trained in labour are taking their roles.

"This is totally inappropriate," the assistant secretary of the NSW Nurses Association, Judith Kiejda, said yesterday. "It's not safe for patients and all they are doing is making their staff dissatisfied and they will leave."

The Australian College of Midwives insists that "delegation of midwifery care to non-midwives is not acceptable".

"It is the right of all women to receive continuous pregnancy, labour, birth and postnatal care from a midwife. Compromising women's midwifery care … with non-midwifery personnel is not an appropriate strategy for addressing shortages of midwives," it says.

But the hospital denies any patients had been put in danger. The director of clinical operations for Sydney West Area Health Service, Kevin Hedge, said the unit usually had two midwives rostered for each shift, but a decision had been made to send the second midwife to work in other wards if there were no women in labour.

"Some theatre nurses have been deployed to maternity to support the midwife but it is only to fill gaps in the roster," he said. "Such arrangements are always temporary and are not continued where the midwife is required in the maternity unit."

The Opposition's health spokeswoman, Jillian Skinner, said the roster was short-changing women admitted for antenatal and postnatal care who still deserved midwifery care.

"There are many women in there who give birth at Nepean and are immediately shipped back to Blue Mountains for postnatal care," she said.

"Why on Earth would you not make the best use of the expertise available? No wonder nurses and midwives are leaving the system. This is an affront to them."

Melissa Maimann, a midwife who runs birthing classes, said nurses were leaving themselves open to deregistration if anything went wrong during labour or birth as only obstetricians and registered midwives were legally covered to deliver babies.

"Not all midwives are nurses," she said, "… so why should they be put on general wards?"

Sunday, December 28, 2008

ABORIGINALS FIGHT FOR LAND

Joel Gibson Indigenous Affairs Reporter, smh

December 28, 2008

ABORIGINES and the NSW Government are at war in the courts over the fate of unused crown land worth billions.

The Government has lost 11 out of 13 appeals against rejected land claims in the past 18 months as Aborigines fight to take back land the Government wants to sell to close its billion-dollar budget black hole.

Land rights officials are accusing the Government of racial discrimination because of the hard line it is taking against Aboriginal groups.

But it will not let up, with two crucial new cases due to come before the Land and Environment Court next year. Neither side would reveal the legal cost of the war, which went to the High Court for the first time in October, but it is understood to be in the millions.

Under the Aboriginal Land Rights Act, Aboriginal land councils in NSW are able to claim unused Crown land on behalf of their members as compensation for their dispossession two centuries ago. But the state's economic woes have forced the Government to adopt a policy, since 2003, of selling it.

A game of real estate cat and mouse has developed, where Aboriginal land councils scour parish maps in search of claimable Crown land. When land is listed in the real estate pages or the Government Gazette, they have until a sale is made to lodge a claim.

The High Court found in October that a disused Wagga Wagga motor registry could be claimed, even though it was for sale.

Two cases in the Land and Environment Court early next year - over blocks in East Lindfield and North Kempsey - will determine whether a notice must appear in the Government Gazette before land is sold, which would make it almost impossible to list it for sale without attracting a land claim.

Other claims to be decided include a section of North Head and a Kiama courthouse. There were just 358 claims before 2000 but there are more than 16,000 now. A quarter have been refused but more than half await assessment.

Meanwhile, the Government has processed successful claims so slowly a 2007 report said it would take more than 20 years to transfer title to more than $1 billion of land already granted to Aborigines.

Geoff Scott, chief executive of the NSW Aboriginal Land Council, said his organisation was considering mounting a racial discrimination case against the Government.

"The Department of Lands policy is to protect the state's assets against marauding blacks. It's as simple as that," he said.

He said land councils wanted to be joint venture partners with the Government, so that both parties reaped the benefits of development.

But the Government says its hands are tied. A Department of Lands spokesman said the Land Rights Act did not give the minister discretion in deciding land claims.

"Lands [Department] will be talking to Aboriginal land council groups and other stakeholders to explore other courses of action. However, there are strong legislative requirements imposed on the minister," he said.

But Steve Wright, the registrar of the Aboriginal Land Rights Act, said claims had been decided by mediation in the past. "There are ways to negotiate this."

CLAIMS

IN ABORIGINAL HANDS

Wagga Wagga A motor registry not used since the 1980s. Warringah Shire Most of Metropolitan Local Aboriginal Land Council's estimated $60 million estate. Kellyville Deerubbin Land Council planning the development of 158 residential blocks on a parcel of claimed land. North Entrance A 101-hectare claim was sold to Mirvac, which built the Magenta Shores golf course and resort. Byron Bay 24 blocks, valued at $100 million, granted to settle a native title claim in 2007. Menai 750 hectares granted to Gandangara Local Aboriginal Land Council in 1999. Morisset 1146 hectares near Morisset Hospital granted in 1995. Stockton Beach Eight parcels of land (total of about 750 hectares) granted in 2002.

TO BE DECIDED

Former government facility at North Head; old courthouse at Kiama; unused public tennis courts at Yanco; land at East Lindfield and North Kempsey.

Saturday, December 27, 2008

MORE MARR ON HANEEF, AND THE POPE

Courage under fire from usual suspects

David Marr, smh

December 27, 2008

With trademark self-absorption, homosexuals are making a fuss over the Pope's remarks about the "ecology of man" delivered pre-Christmas to the Roman Curia. "It is not outmoded metaphysics," Benedict XVI declared, "when the church speaks of the nature of the human being as man and woman, and demands that this order of creation be respected."

Harsh things are being said about His Holiness in the aftermath. But poofs who love the planet more than themselves should acknowledge the pontiff was onto something here: not just saving homosexuals from their "own destruction" but announcing a new role for the church defending "the earth, water, air, as gifts of the creation that belongs to all of us".

This is welcome. At a time when the Rudd Government can only muster the courage to promise 15 per cent cuts in emissions if, maybe, other countries sign up too, the Catholic Church is setting out on a campaign against global warming at least as determined as its historic mission to stamp out gays. Expect a couple of millenniums of persecution. Even burnings. Don't rule out coal miners being refused Communion.

Courage was also the word Kevin Andrews plucked from nowhere to describe his handling of the Haneef matter. "The Australian people expected me to act," said the former minister for immigration this week. "I had the courage to do so."

Did he mean ingenuity? How but by the most ingenious devices could Andrews have remained, as he claims, entirely ignorant of ASIO's cheerful view of Mohamed Haneef until ASIO's submission to the Clarke inquiry was shown to the world in July? He told The Age: "The first I knew of it was when I saw their submission."

Those 13 months of ignorance rank with some of the great blackouts of the Howard era: the five or so years Alexander Downer spent out of the loop as wheat scams to the tune of $300 million crossed the desks of his Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade; the year the whole cabinet remained convinced Iraq bristled with weapons of mass destruction; and the iconic month no one got around to telling the prime minister that kids weren't thrown overboard.

Recall the problem Andrews faced in July last year: Haneef's arrest was a God-given pre-election terrorism scare that would deflate like a used party balloon if the vilified doctor was allowed to go back to work at the Southport Hospital. As Andrews prepared to cancel Haneef's visa on "character" grounds, ASIO kept reporting all around Canberra the doctor was clean.

Andrews says only the "general tenor" ever reached him though ASIO officials were briefing officers of his department almost daily. As Haneef was entering his 10th day of detention without charge in the Brisbane watch house, ASIO put its verdict in writing. Surely that got to Andrews? No. Clarke reports the assessment was delivered to the acting secretary of the Department of Immigration and Citizenship but "Mr Correll did not circulate the report to anyone else in DIAC or to the minister."

How close it came. There must have been days the minister's cuffs almost brushed the file. Did he know not to ask? Is there some wink or nod, some Masonic handshake that tells a minister not to go there?

A thumbs-down from the spooks was all Andrews needed to cancel Haneef's visa and, though he had his lawyers searching in the dimmest recesses of the legislation for help, he never picked up the phone to get ASIO's verdict.

Hours after a Brisbane magistrate granted Haneef bail, Andrews had the rare privilege of attending a meeting of the national security committee of cabinet. ASIO was there. ASIO delivered its unchanged verdict: Haneef was clean. An impeccable source tells me Andrews was in the room at the time.

Not so, according to the then minister. He told Clarke he only arrived in time to hear the Police Commissioner, Mick Keelty, give a briefing on continued police suspicions about the Indian doctor. Immediately after the NSCC dispersed, Andrews cancelled the visa and Haneef stayed behind bars for another fortnight. It's a neat trick we can pull in Australia: imprisonment by ministerial decree …

Though probably the most crucial meeting in the whole Haneef saga, it's another of Canberra's little dark pools. We can't know what went on there. John Howard didn't front the inquiry and Clarke reports that officers of the Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet were told "they could not disclose to me any aspects of the discussion of the matters in question in cabinet or cabinet committees - in particular, at meetings of the National Security Committee." Ingenious.

By the way, Clarke reserves the word "courage" for ASIO. He endorses the view of the Inspector-General of Intelligence and Security, Ian Carnell, who said the organisation "showed good moral courage in expressing its views".

THOUGHTS of courage in adversity at this time bring Conrad Black to mind. The former Fairfax proprietor and convicted fraudster, Black is reviewing books from his Florida prison.

For the online Daily Beast, he's had a go at Michael Wolff's biography of The Man Who Owns The News as "a confusing and cliched account of Rupert Murdoch's life, replete with factual errors, serious omissions, mind-reading suppositions, extreme psychological liberties" etc.

Marcus Einfeld might take up book reviewing to while away the time he's going to be spending in the slammer when he's sentenced on February 25 for telling a few porkies to get out of a $77 speeding fine. Around the courts they reckon he'll be spending a couple of years thereafter behind bars.

Lord Black of Crossharbour is also lining up for a pardon from the departing George Bush - something, alas, Quentin Bryce can't extend to Marcus Einfeld. It's just one more problem we need to address in the constitution.

INDIFFERENCE AND RACISM

Louis Nowra, smh

December 27, 2008

It still comes as a shock to hear racist remarks about Aborigines. A few weeks ago I saw an inebriated Aboriginal woman fall down in a Kings Cross street. A car narrowly missed running over her. While the driver jumped out of his car and rushed to her aid, a crowd of drinkers at the nearby Bourbon hotel laughed at the woman's plight and several shouted out, "Get a look at that drunken Abo". What fascinated me was that the men and women jeering and laughing at her did so without apology as if they knew no one would criticise them. You forget that such casual racism is still a part of our national character.

When I was growing up I never heard my parents make a racist comment. My mother's first husband had been Javanese and two of my aunties also married Indonesian men. I didn't think there was anything unusual about this until I was a teenager when one of my cousins decided to enter the Miss Australia contest. She was beautiful and intelligent. When it looked like she was going to win the state title one of the judges took her aside and said she would have to withdraw because she was coloured. It's all too easy to imagine her profound hurt.

In my early 20s one of my closest friends was a drag queen. He was Aboriginal but told everyone he was Indonesian because, as he once confided in me, he hated being called "a boong" and other such names. My ignorance of such abuse was telling because I thought he was exaggerating. I had no idea, nor did I probably care, of what he had gone through to reach such a stage as to deny his own background.

For most people it is the personal experience that transforms the way you see the world. So it was with me. In my late 30s I began to live with an Aboriginal woman, Justine Saunders. She had come from desperate conditions and had been taken from her mother, placed in a Catholic girls' home and, at the age of 14, forcibly sent to a distant country town to become a maid. She had risen above these circumstances to become a model, then actress on the stage, in film and on television. I remember being in the outback with her once, and a group of Aboriginal children who had just seen her on television rubbed her skin to see if she was really a white woman made up to be black because they just could not imagine a real Aboriginal person being on TV.

There were many things that Justine taught me about the awful, dismal things Aborigines have had done to them and in many parts of Australia still have to endure: the cruel remarks, the constant belittling, the poverty and the cold indifference of government authorities. On the other hand she grew tired of those white people who sought her out as some sort of spiritual guru, just because she was Aboriginal. It was as if she did not exist as a person but as an answer to these white people's lack of their own identity. Perhaps her greatest scorn was for small 'l' liberals who seemed to be merely parroting platitudes about their love for Aborigines; but it always seemed to be talk and no action. "Sometimes I prefer rednecks," she would say after a meeting with such people, "because at least you know where you stand with rednecks."

Through Justine I also got to know many Aborigines, including actors. It was the first time I mixed on such a personal level with actors and I saw aspects of them in private life that I wanted to put on stage. I began to write characters especially for them. I have been asked if I wrote these plays because I was keen to write about Aboriginal "topics". The truth is that I had no ideology. I just wanted to see these men and women playing roles I had written especially for them. Perhaps the culmination of this was the play Radiance. The original production starred Lydia Miller, Rhoda Roberts and Rachel Maza. The idea for it came from a story one Aboriginal woman told me about half-sisters attending the funeral of their mother. During rehearsal it was decided that there would be no mention of the fact that the characters were Aboriginal. We didn't want to write a "problem" play but one about the emotional interplay between three sisters who hardly knew each other and only had their mother in common.

I didn't set out to write a political play but the difficulty about writing for Aboriginal characters is that Aborigines on stage become more than people; they personalise an issue for many critics and audiences. I suppose it was my naivety, but I was amazed when audiences saw it as a work about the stolen generation rather than something more primal and personal.

In 1998 Radiance was made into a film directed by the indigenous film maker Rachel Perkins. She did a superb job. Yet there were a few people, most of them white, who criticised her for being involved in a story written by a non-indigenous writer and a man at that. I was abused by one white woman for "appropriating black women's stories".

In early January 2003 Rachel and her producer, Darren Dale, met me for lunch. They had embarked on an eight-part documentary series for SBS on Aboriginal history and they wanted me to be script editor on episode two, which was centred on the arrival of the English in 1788. I was reluctant because of my lack of time but then the original writer of the episode left and I found myself writing it. A similar thing happened with episode three, and eventually I went on to write eight episodes.

These four years proved to be exhausting, profound, exciting and at times depressing. When you study the history of Aboriginal and white relations since the First Fleet, the great difficulty is dealing with the distressing information that confronts you. It seems that wherever white men appeared in Australia, Aboriginal dispossession, deaths from violence and disease, and suffering followed. It took me some months to be able to deal with such horrific matters.

As our template we used Ken Burns's magnificent The Civil War documentary series, so we wanted to concentrate on characters and story to bring the episodes to life. Of course, at first, we had to depend on white sources - documents, letters and photographs - but it enabled us to find our way to help tell each story.

As time went on I began to realise something - what I was learning was our true Australian history. I loathed Australian history at school. Who can make the Gold Rush or Federation interesting? It's laughable to think that the Eureka Stockade was a major historical moment when compared with what happened in other frontier societies like America.

But Aboriginal history since Governor Philip contains all the elements of an astonishing history: great men and women, evil doers and flawed men, bloodshed, corruption, ideals and government deceit, racial conflict, broken treaties, love and hate, ideological warfare, bad science, companionship and the survival of a people who were thought to be dying out.

Sometimes the stories had Shakespearean grandeur and moral complexity to them, other times they were as grim as a Samuel Beckett play. This history was breathtaking in its scope and its importance to all Australians. I felt I had come to understand that unless we learned this history then Australians were missing out on something extraordinary and essential for an understanding of how we came to be the nation we are.

As the production process continued over the years I became even more aware of the terrible irony that, while the Aboriginal population is increasing rapidly and its artists are celebrated, many of the urban and rural indigenous communities are being torn apart by male violence and sexual abuse. The combination of history, government inertia, welfare dependency and alcohol had created a perfect storm of community dysfunction. So last year I wrote a slim book about it called Bad Dreaming.

The book was based on government reports, anthropologists, historians and journalists and Aborigines themselves. I can claim no originality. I wanted non-indigenous people to understand just what was happening to our indigenous population. Writing the documentary series convinced me that we owed an obligation to help a people we have treated so badly too much of the time. There were critics of course. One Queensland academic ridiculed me, saying:

"Everybody knows what's going on in these communities." Well, as far as the response to Bad Dreaming was concerned, the academic was wrong. I received many letters and emails, some from people who worked with Aborigines who confirmed my research, indigenous men who had tried to do something about the situation but had been ostracised by elders, but the overwhelming reaction from people was, "We didn't know." I have to say that most were horrified not only by the examples I gave but also the fact that they had paid no attention to it before. I was hoping that First Australians would attract such people who wanted to know more about our common history.

Now, as any documentary writer can tell you, a script is merely a vague blueprint that can be considerably altered by the experts you interview and the visual material you can find. Some interviews can totally change the way you approach a topic. And that's what happened in First Australians. Rachel and the other director, Beck Cole, also an indigenous filmmaker, took the scripts and put them through the exhilarating blender of interviews and visuals to create a fabulous series.

Characters like Bennelong, the young Patyregarang, William Dawes, the charismatic William Barak and the heroic and stubborn Eddie Mabo came alive. Above all Rachel and Beck created a documentary series that did not go out of its way to blame white people for what had happened to the Aborigines and Torres Strait Islanders, nor did it portray them as victims as other documentaries had done.

SBS publicised the series brilliantly. The reviews and articles about it were excellent. There were very few negative reactions; perhaps one of the most silly was by Patrick McCauley, in this month's Quadrant, who thought it was another example of the constant reaffirmation of "the invasion/genocide/stolen generation/racist version of Australian history".

The general reaction of people was that they had thought they knew about Aboriginal history, but the series had been a revelation to them.

I was detached enough from First Australians to believe that this wonderful response would result in big audiences. But I was wrong. The numbers generally hovered around the 300,000 mark. A figure that's a little bigger than the quarter of a million people who walked across Sydney Harbour Bridge in the Reconciliation March. To put it into even bigger perspective, a bland middle-class family drama, Packed to the Rafters, attracts about 2 million per episode.

I was mentioning this to a friend, a well known writer. She told me she had not seen the series. "I don't have any excuse," she said. "Actually, to be honest, I am totally indifferent to the whole subject of Aborigines." This stunned me, but I was grateful for her honesty. When you've lived with and worked with Aborigines you forget just how many Australians have never met an indigenous person or really care about them.

And really this goes back to the arrival of settlers. Once the white man discovered that Aborigines had nothing to trade nor did they till the land then they could quite easily be gotten rid of or forgotten. The last 200 years saw them pushed onto poverty-stricken reserves, bleak missions or shunted away in communities or urban ghettos so that the general population did not have to be reminded of them.

Those drinkers heckling the Aboriginal woman who had fallen onto the road expressed not so much their racism but the general populace's attitude towards the first Australians - they are indifferent. It's a shame because our historical identity as Australians is inextricably bound up with the Aborigines and Torres Strait Islanders. I can only hope that a younger generation realises this, because, as far as history proves, indifference can be a callous and even cruel thing.

Louis Nowra is a playwright, novelist and screenwriter. His latest novel is Ice.

LOOPHOLES IN FAIR WORK BILL

New law fails young families

Mark Davis Political Correspondent, smh

December 27, 2008

Latest related coverage:
Maternity leave exposes 'culture of antagonism'

THE Rudd Government's much-vaunted new right for working parents to seek flexible employment arrangements to help with their family responsibilities will turn out to be a "Clayton's right" because it cannot be legally enforced, according to labour law experts.

The Government's Fair Work Bill - due to replace the Howard government's Work Choices next year - gives employees with preschool children a legislated right to request family-friendly work patterns such as different starting and finishing times or part-time employment.

But while the bill says employers may refuse such requests only on "reasonable business grounds", the fine print confirms that where working parents believe their employer has breached this obligation, they will have no means to enforce their right.

A clause in the bill provides that where an employer contravenes the flexible working arrangement requirement, the courts will not be able to impose penalties or issue any other orders enforcing the employee's right. This contrasts with wide powers the bill gives courts to penalise employers who breach any of the other nine of the 10 national employment standards the Government plans to introduce in the legislation.

The framing of the bill comes as a report has found that pregnant women frequently lose their jobs, despite having had legal protection from discrimination for 30 years. The report, by the Women's Employment Rights Project, found the old Work Choices laws had expanded employers' dismissal powers and provided broad operational reasons for making employees redundant.

The bill also bars employers, employees and unions from agreeing to allow the industrial tribunal, Fair Work Australia, to settle individual grievances over refusals of flexible work requests.

Campaigners for women's workplace rights have criticised the Government for watering down the requirement that employers must not unreasonably refuse requests for flexible working arrangements for parents of young children.

The director of the University of South Australia's Centre for Work and Life, Barbara Pocock, said legal rights were meaningful only if they were backed up by sanctions for non-compliance.

"The concern is what happens in workplaces where the employer is intransigent or where the internal culture is hostile towards workers with family responsibilities," Professor Pocock said.
"It really runs the risk of being a Clayton's right, one the Government can say it has provided but where the reality is a long way short of such a right.

"If the employee knows that where they get a knock-back from the employer there will be no avenue of appeal or review, the right becomes very weak or in practical terms, non-existent."

The president of the ACTU, Sharan Burrow, said she was extremely disappointed "the Government had buckled to employer pressure by backing down on what it promised".

"To be meaningful, there must be an external review process available to employees when their boss refuses to consider their request for more flexible hours," Ms Burrow said.

"Under the proposed legislation, employers will have no obligation to consider other ways to accommodate workers with family responsibilities."

The Minister for Workplace Relations, Julia Gillard, said the national standards on flexible work and a similar one allowing employees to ask for an extra 12 months' maternity leave were designed to promote discussion between employers and employees.

"They are not intended to be prescriptive as this is likely to act as a disincentive to genuine discussion," she said.

"The bill does not identify what may, or may not, comprise reasonable business grounds. The Government believes such matters are appropriately assessed at the workplace level."

Friday, December 26, 2008

INCREASE IN XMAS ISLAND DETAINEES

Ronan O'Connell, smh

December 26, 2008

STAFF at Christmas Island's main detention centre have been told to prepare for the arrival of about 70 more boat people in what would be the biggest single influx into Australian territory this year.

It is understood that staff at the $400 million North West Point detention centre have been told that the refugees could arrive within a week. They would bring to about 150 the number of asylum seekers to be transported to the island in the space of a month.

A week ago, 37 people were taken to the remote Indian Ocean island and less than two weeks before that 44 people, believed to be from Afghanistan, were transported there.

The total would be more than the 148 illegal immigrants intercepted at sea in all of last year.

The RAAF has at least three P3 Orion aircraft at Exmouth in Western Australia conducting regular surveillance, and a navy patrol boat has been anchored off Christmas Island.

At present 171 asylum seekers and illegal boat crew are being held on Christmas Island, with 113 of them housed in the North West Point detention centre, which was opened last week.

The construction camp on the island houses 29 refugees and one boat crew member, while the Phosphate Hill camp is empty after its occupants were shifted to North West Point.

A spokesman for the Department of Immigration said the detainees would be placed in community accommodation once health, identity and security checks had been completed.

Twenty-eight asylum seekers live in the community and are allowed to move freely throughout the island.

The 171 asylum seekers and boat crew are made up of Afghans, Iranians, Iraqis, Sri Lankans and Indonesians.

A spokesman for the Minister for Home Affairs, Bob Debus, would not deny that the Government was expecting the arrival of more boat people in the coming days.

However, a spokesman for the Minister for Immigration, Chris Evans, said he was not aware of any impending arrival.

The Rudd Government has softened its stance on the detention of asylum seekers by abolishing temporary protection visas and ending the so-called Pacific solution introduced under John Howard.

Its moves against hard-line detention are believed to be behind the initial reluctance to open the new Christmas Island centre that was commissioned by the Howard Government following the Tampa affair in 2001.

Refugee advocates have complained that the continuing detention of asylum seekers on Christmas Island and the decision to open the centre raised concerns about the Rudd Government's commitment to its police of "detention as a last resort".

Senator Evans has said that all unauthorised boat arrivals would be detained and processed at Christmas Island while health, identity and security checks are carried out.

The West Australian

Thursday, December 25, 2008

MARR ON HANEEF

On day two, ASIO knew he was clean

David Marr, smh

December 24, 2008

Latest related coverage

No grudges, and he may even return
Advice from ASIO was ignored by police
Questions over delay in releasing report
Clarke gets inquiry done despite no-shows and other hurdles
Howard's sedition laws to be abolished

Editorial: The Christmas call to hope

Audio: Dr Haneef reacts to findings

Other related coverage

Jury verdict in London clears way for judgment on Haneef fiasco

MICK KEELTY is no more than a ghost in the Clarke report. Though the Australian Federal Police are revealed on page after page to have made an absolute mess of the case, Commissioner Keelty is barely an extra in the narrative. He gets three mentions in the first 100 pages. There's no discussion of his direction - or failure to direct - the officers below him. There are no findings on his role. Nothing.

Keelty appears to be a protected species. Both the Attorney-General, Robert McClelland, yesterday and the former NSW Supreme Court judge John Clarke, QC, in his report share the notion that the AFP's most senior officer is somehow not responsible for the glaring faults exposed in its senior ranks. Clarke makes no bones of it - the evidence against Mohamed Haneef was "completely deficient".

He blames one man above all for the mess: the federal police's Manager Counter Terrorism Domestic, Commander Ramzi Jabbour. Though Clarke called him "impressive, dedicated and capable", he found Jabbour had lost objectivity and was "unable to see that the evidence he regarded as highly incriminating in fact amounted to very little".

Once the British police discovered Haneef was no longer in Britain, they all but lost
interest in the case. Not Jabbour. He persuaded reluctant police to arrest Haneef as he was about to board a plane to India. It was a "cynical" Jabbour, said Clarke, who kept evidence that might exonerate Haneef from the magistrate detaining the doctor in the Brisbane watch-house and from the then minister for immigration, Kevin Andrews, who was to cancel his visa.

In popular mythology, police are the hard heads and spooks the dreamers. But Clarke reveals a pattern in this case of ASIO giving Haneef a clean bill of health while the police, led by Jabbour, continued to put the worst possible slant on the scant evidence against him.

Clarke writes that Haneef could be held without charge only while police continued to have "reasonable grounds" to believe he had committed a terrorist crime. But as the days passed and no information turned up to contradict Haneef's story, that belief became "difficult to sustain", said Clarke. "The 'evidence' supporting this premise consisted largely of Commander Jabbour's asserted experience in counter-terrorism."

Two heroes emerge from Clarke's narrative. Federal agent Neil Thompson of the federal police and Detective Sergeant Adam Simms of the Queensland Police were the officers who had to be persuaded to arrest Haneef and the ones who interrogated him over the best part of 24 hours, at the end of which they refused to put their names to any charges.

Clarke wrote: "Simms and Thompson told the inquiry that the usual course would be for them, as the arresting officers, to make the decision about whether or not to charge, and that consequently they felt 'under considerable pressure' at this time. Both said, however, that in their opinion there was insufficient evidence, and they refused to charge Dr Haneef."

So Jabbour took over and charged the doctor with recklessly assisting a terrorist organisation by giving his cousin Sabeel Ahmed an old SIM card - still registered in his name - one year before Sabeel's brother tried and failed to blow up a London nightclub and Glasgow Airport.

Though the charge was withdrawn after only a fortnight in a welter of public embarrassment, the federal police continued to pursue Haneef. Simms got a trip to Britain out of it and there discovered how easy it is to buy a SIM card in anyone's name, real or false. He told Clarke "he wished that 'someone had come forward and said that a lot earlier', noting that it 'begs the question as to why terrorists would want to use SIM cards that are registered in the names of affiliates, associates or relatives. It just doesn't stand to reason'."

It never did. Clarke talks like an old judge but without a judge's power. He doesn't allow himself to reach cut and dried conclusions. Everything is veiled in the languid rhetoric of concern, surprise, bewilderment, etc. "I record my surprise that not one of the people involved in the police investigation and the charging whom the inquiry interviewed stood back at any time prior to the decision to charge and reflected on what Dr Haneef was known to have done."

Bugger all. Aficionados of the case will find hundreds of fascinating details in the report that clarify the complicated interaction of police, ASIO and the minister's office. We discover that though Haneef was begging to be allowed to talk to his wife, it took the federal police eight days to do it. Clarke refused to accept police claims that such contact might have allowed the prisoner to wreck the case.

ASIO's role behind the scenes is the most eye-opening aspect. We knew it had cleared Haneef before he was charged. What now emerges is that within 48 hours of his arrest ASIO told the government in writing that it "had not identified information to suggest that Haneef: posed a specific threat to security, in Australia or overseas; was planning to undertake an act of violence in Australia or elsewhere; was involved in, or had foreknowledge of, the failed UK attacks."

That advice never changed. It proved correct. But the government essentially ignored it. The federal police come out as cowboys and ASIO as the cool professionals. But the cowboys were running the show.

Jabbour gets another caning: "There does not appear to have been any systematic process for recording and updating the information received in the course of the investigation and for keeping track of significant avenues of inquiry for the purposes of assessing the grounds for the belief that Dr Haneef had committed an offence . . . In the absence of such a process, any review by Jabbour of the reasonableness of his belief was likely to have been an impressionistic exercise."

This was the first time the new machinery of detention without charge had been used. Guarantees against misuse of the system are theoretically provided by the oversight of a magistrate, in this case Jim Gordon of Brisbane. But Clarke shows how difficult Gordon's position was. Essentially he was flying blind with only the information police let him have.

Clarke found Haneef "was not told he had a right to personally make representations to the magistrate" and his lawyers never saw sensitive intelligence evidence against him. The material the police gave the magistrate was seriously inaccurate and did not include important evidence that supported Haneef's innocence. Clarke keeps some of his strongest language in reserve for urging changes to a system with "simply no provision covering procedural fairness problems".
That there is presently no limit to the time a person can be held without charge he calls "the most obvious deficiency" of the legislation.

But he also recommends the machinery be operated only by skilled lawyers and senior police, which was not the case with Haneef's detention. "Having regard to the fundamental importance of the extended deprivation of liberty, there is a strong case for requiring the application to be made by more senior officers, trained in the process and familiar with all the facts, including those arising in sensitive material."

All that is for down the track. Nothing in the report mattered so much to Haneef yesterday as Clarke's simple exoneration on its opening page: "I could find no evidence that he was associated with or had foreknowledge of the terrorist events or of the possible involvement of his second
cousins Dr Sabeel Ahmed and Mr Kafeel Ahmed in terrorist activities.'

Tuesday, December 23, 2008

ZIMBABWE NEEDS HELP!!

Out of Africa, a cry for help

"We need outside assistance" … the Zimbabwean opposition politician Brian James.

Latest related coverage:

Unity pact dead with Mugabe at helm: US

Other related coverage:

Mugabe claims cholera epidemic over
'Zimbabwe is mine': Mugabe defiant as criticism mounts
Mugabe says he will never surrender

December 23, 2008

Brian James took up Robert Mugabe's call. Now he's been run off his farm, writes Russell Skelton, smh.

BRIAN JAMES resents the suggestion that the people of Zimbabwe should do more to rid themselves of the disaster that is the Mugabe regime.

"What more can people do?" he says. "People voted for change and then had the election stolen.

People lost their lives and political abductions are still going on. We have 40 members of the MDC [Movement for Democratic Change] unaccounted for. There is a systemic culture of fear."

The popularly elected mayor of Mutare, Zimbabwe's third-largest city with a population of nearly 300,000, Mr James is a prominent member of Opposition Leader Morgan Tsvangirai's MDC.

He is also one of a handful of popularly elected white politicians that have survived the era of liberation politics that began with President Robert Mugabe.

Mr James is a second generation Zimbabwean who took up farming after hearing Mr Mugabe's independence speech in 1980 calling for the nation to pull together. Twenty years later he was run off his farm. He is in Melbourne to visit his daughter before travelling to New Zealand.

The mayor said he welcomed the United States's decision to call the power sharing agreement between Mr Mugabe and Mr Tsvangirai "dead" on the grounds that "Mugabe had lost touch with reality".

The US Assistant Secretary of State, Jendayi Frazer, announced yesterday that the Bush Administration would continue to impose sanctions on Zimbabwe because Mr Mugabe had "reneged on the principle of power sharing".

"We need this outside pressure, it all helps. Our treason laws are such that it is impossible to call for anything … We need outside assistance," Mr James said.

He said Mr Mugabe's response - a threat to call a snap election - was full of bravado because he knew he would lose. "I would welcome an election especially if it was held under international supervision, there could be no escaping the verdict."

Mr James said he was initially discouraged from entering politics by members of the country's diminished white community who thought it best for business to avoid being identified with the MDC. "Some white business interests are working with the Government, they are helping to prop it up. When this is all over, there will be a need for a truth and reconciliation commission."

Cholera has spread to Mutare and the crisis is far from over despite claims by Mr Mugabe that it is. "We are worried that a nest of cholera could develop in the city, because the whole infrastructure including the sewerage system is in decay."

The disease has already claimed 1123 lives and aid agencies have warned that another 60,000 are likely to be infected unless decisive action is taken.

Elsewhere the situation continues to deteriorate with reports of corruption and extravagance among the military and the ruling political elite intensifying. Members of the elite send their children abroad to be educated while teachers go without basic pay. Local markets are bereft of food, but supermarkets for the wealthy remain well stocked.

Mr James remains optimistic. He said that even in Mutare, where Zanu-PF party members sit on the council, there was an increasing consensus. "There is a growing moderate group in the Zanu-PF that knows this cannot continue, that wants change."

Mr Mugabe's statements at the weekend that Zimbabwe was his and that he would "never surrender" would have been counterproductive. "We work on three pillars of principle: democracy, transparency and accountability. We explain to the people of Mutare what the hurdles are and I believe we have their backing, especially when it comes to transparency.

"The people are enthusiastic for change and we are feeding on that. These are poor people but the enthusiasm they have has opened my eyes to what was being felt across the entire country. It has kept me going."

NURSE CUTS PURELY ECONOMIC

From SMH, 23.12.08:

The Health Department's assertion that the reduction of registered nurse numbers in rural hospitals is because many patients are low-care cases waiting for nursing home placement is patently wrong ("Skilled nurses axed in cost cuts", December 19).

I am a registered nurse at Moruya Hospital. This is a busy district hospital with regular surgical and gynaecological operating lists, a busy maternity department, a medical-surgical high dependency unit, a renal dialysis unit, oncology and a busy accident and emergency department.

Greater Southern Area Health Service is cutting registered nurse positions in all these acute areas and has closed the long-stay ward so that for the first time there are regularly patients on trolleys all night waiting for beds. These cuts are obviously economic and not in the interests of patients, staff or efficiency.

Joy Fenn Moruya

TRAINED NURSES ESSENTIAL

From SMH 22.12.08

After years of concern about standards of care and untimely deaths in the NSW hospital system, the Government has just paid millions of dollars for the Garling report. Was this all just window dressing?

Now NSW Health comes up with a plan to downskill the nursing workforce further by making half the workforce in rural hospitals untrained nursing assistants ("Skilled nurses axed in cost cuts", December 19).

It comforts itself that these staff will be supervised by a registered nurse, but they are increasingly new graduates, as the older staff retire. Placing increasing pressure on new graduates will do nothing for their retention in the workforce.

Jenny Haines Newtown

Aged people with dementia require skilled nurses to care for them - registered nurses as well as enrolled nurses and assistants in nursing.

NSW Health says the cuts are justified as many hospitals are working as aged care facilities, which implies that aged care facilities require only basic nursing skills.

Yes, aged care facilities send their residents to hospital for treatment, as there is inadequate coverage by GPs. But caring for the sick elderly in the aged care facilities provides better outcomes with qualified staff who know them. It is also much cheaper.

Anyone who has cared for a person with dementia, who most likely also has other diagnoses, knows the skill, education and experience required.

With skilled registered nurses and adequate GP services, these people can be cared for without transferring them to hospital, where their confused state is only exacerbated by the unfamiliar environment. Having more aged care beds, with qualified staff, will keep acute beds free.

Rosemary McDonald Towradgi